What Happens When a Mentor Coach Recognizes the Client in a Recording?

In my practice, when I recognize the client, I stop the recording and don’t listen to the rest. I ask the coach to go back to the client with two questions: are they okay with me hearing their coaching sessions, and with me hearing the one already submitted? Then I wait for their answer.

I’m Cherie Silas. I hold the Master Certified Coach (MCC) credential awarded by the International Coaching Federation (ICF), and I mentor coaches. Tandem sells mentor coaching and trains mentor coaches, so you should know that as you read.

Under the ICF mentor coaching requirements, a coach preparing an ICF credential application at the Associate Certified Coach (ACC), Professional Certified Coach (PCC) or MCC level works with a mentor coach on recordings of real coaching sessions. The guidance I see on confidentiality in coaching speaks to the coach who makes the recording: how coaches maintain client confidentiality when they record a session and share it. Coaching ethics has a listener’s side too.

This is that side, from my own coaching practice. What happens if you get a recording you’re reviewing and you think, “I know this client”? That has actually happened to me more than once, as a mentor.

Key Takeaways

  • When I recognized the client in a mentee’s recording, I stopped it and didn’t listen to the rest.
  • The client had given permission to share the recording with “your mentor.” They didn’t know the mentor was me, someone who knows them.
  • I asked the coach to take two questions back to the client: one about coaching sessions still to come, one about the recording already submitted. I didn’t contact the client myself.
  • The client said no to that recording and set their own terms for later ones. My answer was “Perfect.”
  • Stopping and asking is what I do in my practice. The ICF Code of Ethics asks for the strictest level of confidentiality regardless of role, and mentor coach is one of those roles.

Stop Listening the Moment You Recognize the Client

Here’s one of those times. The coach had permission from the client to submit the recording. The coach didn’t know that I knew the client. The coach and the client lived clear across the country from one another.

When I heard the client’s voice, I thought, “I think I know this voice.” And when I heard the scenario, I thought, “I know who this person is.”

So I stopped the recording and didn’t listen to the rest of it.

That was my first move, before the rest of the coaching conversation played and before I said a word to the coach. For me, mentor coaching confidentiality begins with the listener: the moment I recognize the client, I stop hearing their coaching session until they’ve had a say in it.

ICF sets its own wording on confidentiality. Stopping was my call as the mentor. It’s my way of honoring confidentiality in my practice, and how I protect client privacy when I’m the one listening.

The Client’s First Yes Was to “Your Mentor”

I went back to the mentee and told them, “I know who this client is. I understand they gave you permission to share it with your mentor, but they didn’t know I was your mentor.”

The reason is in that sentence. What the client agreed upon was a mentor they didn’t know. A mentor who knows them is a different listener, and the client’s yes didn’t reach that far.

ICF’s wording frames this. The ICF Code of Ethics defines confidentiality as “the protection of any information obtained in or around the coaching relationship unless there is a legal reason or requirement, a threat of harm, or written consent to release is given by the client.” Its standard 2.1 reads: “Maintain the strictest level of confidentiality with all parties involved, regardless of the role I am fulfilling.” Mentor coach is one of those roles. When I review a mentee’s recording, I maintain confidentiality for their client as well, and everything I hear on it is confidential information about that client.

ICF describes mentor coaches as experienced coaches who give feedback on observed or recorded coaching sessions, so a coach can develop their coaching skills in line with the ICF Core Competencies. Mentor coaching exists for coaches to learn from that feedback, and every recording puts a real client’s privacy in the mentor’s hands. The first of the six Mentor Coaching Competencies, “Models and Promotes Ethical Practice,” reads: “Models ethical standards and encourages the mentor coaching client to do the same.” Those six describe mentoring a coach, a different framework from the eight Core Competencies that describe coaching a client. They sit behind the ICF Mentor Coach Specialization.

Two Questions Go Back to the Client, Through the Coach

Then I told the mentee what I needed: “I need you to go back and ask them whether they’re okay with you sharing your coaching sessions with me, and whether it’s okay for me to listen to the one you already submitted.”

And I told them why:

I’m not going to listen to it until I have their permission.

That’s two questions. The first is about the coaching sessions still to come. The second is about the recording already in my hands. Each one gets its own answer.

The coach needs to go back to the client, and I asked the coach to do the asking. I didn’t contact the client, and I didn’t decide for them. The coaching agreement is between the coach and their client, and the coach is the one who has to maintain trust with that client. The client consent I needed was consent for me in particular.

On the mentee’s side, preparing for mentor coaching means sending a consent form with each recording, from every client whose session you share. Knowing someone in a recording also raises conflicts of interest and bias, and the bias check for familiar faces covers that part.

Wait for the Answer, and Take a No as Good News

Then I waited for the client’s answer.

It turned out the client said, “I don’t want her to listen to that recording. But now that I know who your mentor is, I won’t bring topics that person shouldn’t hear to the sessions we record for you to turn in.”

Perfect.

That’s how we handled it.

The client said no to one recording and set their own terms for the sessions they would record later. It’s their coaching engagement, and what they share in confidence with their coach is their call.

I asked for an answer, and I got one. A no is an answer. The question went to the person it belonged to, and they decided who hears their sessions.

If You Mentor Coaches, or Send Your Recordings to One

If you mentor coaches, or you’re a mentor in training, here’s what I did, in order: I stopped the recording, told the coach, sent two questions back to the client through the coach, waited, and took the answer I got.

If your recordings go to a mentor, your mentor may come back to you one day with those two questions. The answer is your client’s to give. When you choose a mentor, ask how recordings stay confidential. And if you want a mentor coach for your own credential, Tandem’s mentor coaching for ACC, PCC and MCC is where to start.

Frequently Asked Questions About Client Confidentiality in Mentor Coaching

Do you finish listening to a recording when you recognize the client?

Not in my practice. When I recognized the client, I stopped the recording and didn’t listen to the rest of it. The coaching work on that recording waited for the client’s answer.

Does the mentor coach contact the client directly?

I didn’t. I asked the coach to go back and ask the client. The coach holds the coaching relationship with their client.

What if the client says no?

In my case, the client didn’t want me to listen to that recording, and said they wouldn’t bring topics I shouldn’t hear to the sessions they recorded later. My answer was “Perfect.” Maintaining client confidentiality there meant the client decided.

What Is Executive Communication?

Executive communication is how a senior leader shares information, asks for decisions and sets direction at the level where the organization’s decisions get made. It means the right level of detail for the room and the answer first. It also means listening before arguing and speaking for the whole company.

“You don’t communicate like an executive.” A boss says it in a promotion conversation, usually right after telling you how good your work is. Then the conversation moves on, and you are left to work out what it meant. So you search for executive communication and find advice about slides and speaking voices.

The feedback is about level. What got you to this level is the thing holding you back from the next one. Each part of the feedback points to something your boss watched you do, and each one has a test you can run in your next meeting.

Key Takeaways

  • “You don’t communicate like an executive” is feedback about level. Your boss already rates your work; they cannot yet picture you operating one level up.
  • The habits behind it show up in meetings: the wrong level of detail, talking over people, fighting for your idea to win and speaking only for your department.
  • At the next level, give the answer first, ask before you argue and talk about the company’s trade-offs.
  • The free ACE Check (Authority, Context, Expression) names which of the three gaps is behind your version of the feedback.

What Changes When Communication and Leadership Move Up a Level

At the next level, communication and leadership become the same job. Executive-level communication is how you interact with people where the decisions get made: you listen, ask the right questions, connect the pieces and weigh what matters for the whole organization. Your output stops being the thing you are known for.

A manager or a director is known for how much gets done. At the next level, that is the wrong thing to be known for. Executive leaders are known for vision. They set the pace, clear obstacles and have ideas that take the company three years into the future. A strong executive team wants a peer who sees the bigger picture, and the business leaders above you look for that before they promote anyone. If you are not sure what that looks like in your function, read what strategic thinking means at director and VP level.

What got you to this level is not going to get you to the next level.

The way senior leaders communicate changes for a plain reason: an executive’s words carry more weight. A 2025 Harvard Business Review tip puts it this way: “At this level, your words carry greater weight, and your silence does too.” An offhand comment from the top can shift strategy. The way executives operate in a meeting reflects that. They ask more questions than they offer ideas, and when they do speak, people pay attention because what they say is strategic.

The habits that earned your reputation are the ones your boss is now describing, and the strength that got you promoted is usually the hardest one to put down.

What “You Don’t Communicate Like an Executive” Actually Means

When a boss says you don’t communicate like an executive, they are describing a level, and they rarely spell it out. The feedback usually arrives in a promotion conversation wrapped in praise, and it points to specific habits in how you run a meeting, report your work and deal with your peers.

A boss will say some version of this: “People think you’re brilliant. They think you do a fabulous job. But they don’t see you as a VP. You don’t talk like the VPs talk.” Each sentence in that speech maps to something they watched you do.

What you hearWhat your boss sawThe test for your next meeting
“You’re down in the weeds.”Someone who can churn out the work and get the job done. Nobody mentions strategy when your name comes up.Can you say what your work changes for the company in one sentence?
“You give the wrong amount of detail.”The point buried under the story of how you got there.Does your first sentence state the decision?
“You don’t know your audience.”One communication style for every room, from your own team to the board.What does this room need to decide?
“You talk over people.”Your view lands before anyone else finishes theirs.Who spoke last before you did?
“You fight for your idea to win.”Concerns treated as opposition, and peers who feel you compete with them.Did you ask about the concern before you answered it?
“You only focus on your stuff.”Your department’s results, never the company’s trade-offs.Did you name the other functions your decision touches?

Notice the unspoken part of that message: your boss already rates your ability. They watched you do the previous level’s job very well, and the habits that made you good at it read as ineffective communication one level up. In this sense, ineffective means the room cannot picture you as one of them yet.

For the word “presence” itself, read what your boss means when they say you need executive presence. If you want to know which part of the table is yours, the short ACE Check sorts it in about three minutes.

I Did the Work of Four People and Got Fired Instead of Promoted

I know this feedback from the inside. I was doing the work of four people, and I could not get promoted. Everybody handed me the work that was failing, because they knew I could make it work. I took that as proof that I was ready for the next level, and I was wrong.

I spent my time thinking about how well I ran my own department: getting things done, delivering, improving processes. That is a director’s job. A VP is measured on something else, and I could not see the difference. I did not understand that the problem was how I dealt with people, or that I was not strategic.

I got fired instead of getting promoted. Then I had to take a hard look at myself, and what I found was simple and unpleasant: “I am not as great as I thought I was.” Once I could see how I interacted with people, I could change it. From there, it worked. I became a far better communicator, and today, as a Master Certified Coach, I spot my old habits quickly in the leaders I work with.

Leaving does not fix it either. You can interview well, land a next-level title at another company and struggle there, because you still do not know how to work at that level. Some people who take that route end up more frustrated than before and on the edge of getting fired.

The Right Level of Detail: Answer First, Then Stop

The right level of detail is the least your audience needs to make the decision in front of them. Give the answer first, then only the reasons this room needs, and stop. Everything else waits until someone asks. Detail was your currency at the last level; here it hides your point.

When you were proving yourself, the breakdown proved you did the work. Senior leadership already assumes you did the work. They want the insight: what changed, what it means and what you need from them. A good executive gives the right level of information for the room, and the C-suite and the board need far less of the breakdown than your own team does.

Answer first has a long history. Barbara Minto’s Pyramid Principle, which grew out of her years at McKinsey, starts with the main idea and then groups the supporting points under it. Communicating with executives works the same way. Your first sentence states the recommendation or the decision you need. The second gives the reason. Complex ideas fit this format too, and the structure is what lets people immediately grasp them.

Slides are where the overload shows. A deck crammed with bullets and charts tells senior leaders you could not decide what mattered. Edward Tufte made a related case in The Cognitive Style of PowerPoint: slide templates weaken the reasoning in a presentation. Put the decision on the slide and the breakdown in an appendix.

Under pressure, the instinct is to add detail so you look prepared. Lack of clarity costs you people’s attention faster than a missing number does. To communicate with clarity, write the one-sentence message you want them to remember, then check that every slide and every minute helps convey it. Being concise is a choice you make before the meeting. Too much detail is usually the first sign people point to when they describe what a lack of executive presence looks like in a meeting.

You will find lists such as Forrester’s four Cs of executive communications from 2017. They were written for the communications team that supports executives, so they will not tell you what to say in your own meetings.

Listening, Talking Over People and Fighting for Your Idea to Win

When a leader tells me people weren’t listening in a meeting, I ask what happened. Usually people raised concerns, asked questions and challenged the direction. They did not accept the idea as presented. That is listening. The leader heard it as people getting in the way of their success.

Concerns are information. Your peers want the same thing you want: the company to succeed. When you hear their questions as nitpicking, you turn allies and partners into barriers and obstacles. You also stop hearing what they know that you don’t.

Talking over people and competing with peers look different from the other side of the table. Your colleagues stop bringing you their objections. They save them for the meeting you are not in. Every time you win the argument, you lose a little more of the room, and you keep shooting yourself in the foot.

At the next level, the leadership skills that count are about how you interact with people, starting with being able to listen. Persuasion still matters. Persuasion that only works by winning reads as the old level.

At the next level, it is about asking the right questions, not giving the right answers.

Take a made-up example. A peer questions your rollout plan in front of the leadership team. The old move is to defend every point, faster and louder. The next-level move is to ask the peer to clarify the concern and repeat it back before you answer the part that matters to the decision. Same plan, same meeting. The second version keeps open communication with someone you will need next quarter, and it shows confidence under scrutiny where the first one shows defensiveness.

So ask yourself: who spoke last in your last meeting, and what did you do with their concern? Speaking first and loudest is how leaders end up with the title but not the room.

From Your Department to the Company

The last shift is scope. A director talks about the department; an executive talks about the company. The tell is easy to spot in your own updates: if every one starts with your team’s KPIs and your initiative, your boss hears someone speaking for one corner of the organization.

The shift sounds like this. Name the other functions a decision touches. Name each stakeholder’s trade-off. Say what you would give up for the greater good, and prioritize against the company’s strategic goals. The priority list your team members and direct reports care about comes second. When priorities collide, say which one should win for the company, even when it costs your department.

How much you get done is the wrong thing to be known for at this level. The people above you want to hear what you see three years out. If that kind of thinking feels foreign, start with how to think more strategically, then bring one company-level observation to your next leadership meeting.

How to Learn to Communicate Like an Executive: Three Tests for Your Next Meeting

You learn to communicate like an executive by changing what you do in the next meeting, then checking what other people saw. Reading about it changes nothing on its own. Run these three tests this week, one per meeting. Watch how the room responds each time.

  1. Open with the answer. Start your next update with one sentence: the decision or the recommendation. Watch whether the questions that follow are about the decision or about the detail.
  2. Ask before you argue. In your next disagreement, ask one question about the concern before you state your view. Watch whether the other person adds something you did not know.
  3. Cut the deck. Reduce your next presentation to the decision and the reasons for it, and move everything else to an appendix. Watch whether anyone asks for the appendix.

Then use your next one-on-one with your boss. Ask, “What did you see in that meeting?” and listen to the answer without explaining yourself.

This skill takes months to strengthen. The leaders I have seen make the shift looked different to the people around them six to twelve months later: they listened, they thought about the company’s success before their own, and they communicated with people the way people want to be communicated with. That timeline is what I observe, and it is no promise. If one test keeps failing, there are exercises matched to the gap you actually have.

The ACE Framework for Reading Your Feedback

The ACE Framework (Authority, Context, Expression) names three ways executive presence breaks down. Expression: your thinking does not show. Authority: you still operate the way that got you promoted. Context: your style was tuned for a different audience. The free ACE Check, nine statements in about three minutes, names which one leads.

The behaviors in this article lean one way. Talking over people, fighting for your idea to win and burying the point in detail sit closest to Authority, because they belong to the role you held before. “You don’t know your audience” can point to Context. If your version of the feedback is that nobody knows what you think, that is closer to Expression. These are tendencies. I cannot tell you from here which gap leads for you. The check will.

One condition decides whether any of this works: you have to be ready to hear that you are the problem, and that only you can change it. If you want to be agreed with, this work will frustrate you. I will tell you what I see, and it will not be comfortable. The work is for results other people can see, and for the leadership presence the next level expects.

For the wider picture, read how to develop executive presence. If your boss wants to invest in you, send them to the executive presence training program.

Frequently Asked Questions About Executive Communication

What are executive communication skills?

Executive communication skills are the habits that let senior leaders communicate clearly where decisions get made: the right level of detail, the answer first, listening before arguing, asking questions and speaking for the company. Effective communication at this level is judged by the decisions it produces and by whether people keep bringing you their concerns.

How is executive communication different from public speaking?

Public speaking is delivery to an audience. Executive communication happens mostly in meetings and short conversations. It is judged on what you chose to say, what you left out and how you handled the concern someone raised. Strong communication skills on a stage will not fix the wrong level of detail in a staff meeting.

How do I stop giving too much detail to senior leaders?

Write your first sentence before the meeting: the decision or the recommendation. Add only the reasons this audience needs to agree or decide, and keep the breakdown for questions. If nobody asks for it, they did not need it. That habit is how you communicate effectively with people who have ten minutes for your topic.

Is executive communication the same as executive presence?

They overlap. Executive presence is the wider judgment people make about whether you belong at the next level, and how you communicate is one part of it. Sylvia Hewlett’s executive presence model lists communication as one of three pillars. The free ACE Check (Authority, Context, Expression) shows which gap is behind the feedback you keep hearing.

Can I fix how I communicate on my own, or do I need an executive coach?

Start on your own: run the three tests above and take the free ACE Check. If the same feedback keeps coming back after a few months, an executive coach can show you what you cannot see from inside your own habits. Coaching for executive presence works on these patterns, and it works when you are ready to look at your own part. The aim is clarity and confidence in the rooms that decide your next role.

How Is MCC Mentor Coaching Different From PCC Mentor Coaching?

In my practice, MCC mentor coaching is 10 hours, all one-on-one, because the differences between PCC and MCC are too fine for a group. I often review five or six recordings until three meet the MCC BARS (Behaviorally Anchored Rating Scales), and we plan about a year, usually starting before the coach reaches 2,500 hours.

I’m Cherie Silas. I hold the Master Certified Coach (MCC) credential awarded by the International Coaching Federation (ICF), and I mentor coaches toward it. Tandem sells MCC mentor coaching, so you should know that as you read.

This article is for a credentialed coach who has earned an ICF credential as an ICF Professional Certified Coach (PCC) and wants the ICF Master Certified Coach credential next. The way I look at it, MCC is 2,500 hours of coaching experience, five times more experience than PCC, so the level of coaching is much higher than PCC level. The ICF requirements for the MCC credential itself are in our guide to ICF MCC requirements. Here I’ll stay with the mentoring.

Mentor coaching toward MCC runs differently in my practice. It’s all one-on-one, it takes more recordings and we plan it over about a year.

Key Takeaways

  • In my practice, MCC mentor coaching is all one-on-one. The differences between PCC and MCC are too fine to get to in a group.
  • Plan for more recordings than the three-form minimum. I often review five or six before three meet the MCC BARS.
  • Plan for about a year, and start before you reach 2,500 hours.
  • Needing more mentoring, or waiting, is one of the ordinary ways MCC mentoring goes.
  • ICF has said that from January 1, 2027, new MCC mentor coaching must come from a mentor coach who holds the Mentor Coach Specialization at MCC level.

Why My MCC Mentor Coaching Is All One-on-One

At the Associate Certified Coach (ACC) level and at PCC, the coaches I mentor get individual and group mentor coaching. That changes at MCC. It’s all one-on-one mentor coaching, because you’re not going to get to the differences between PCC and MCC in a group mentoring session.

They deserve one-on-one feedback, because the things that make MCC can be so minute. You’re working at a skill level where it’s hard to describe what it is, because it’s so integrated. So we need to look at multiple recordings, basically line by line.

That’s my mentor coaching practice, and it’s the way Tandem’s MCC package runs. ICF sets its own mentor coaching requirements for how the hours are delivered. One-on-one is my choice, and for what ICF requires, read the ICF mentor coaching hour rules in our guide.

10 Hours of Mentor Coaching, Planned Over About a Year

I only do MCC as 10 hours of one-on-one mentor coaching, and I give feedback on several recorded coaching sessions. ICF’s Accreditation Alignment and Compliance Guide sets a minimum of three Session Observation Forms and one Competency Review Form for each mentoring client, and at MCC I plan for more recordings than that. (At MCC, ICF has said those forms aren’t required for submission.)

It generally takes people more than three recordings to get to MCC. I might do five or six recordings until we get three that meet the MCC BARS (Behaviorally Anchored Rating Scales) and show that they’re successful.

A lot of times they won’t be successful, and they’ll either need more mentoring or they’ll wait. Needing additional mentor coaching, or waiting, is one of the ordinary ways this goes at MCC.

That’s why, when people sign up for MCC mentoring, we generally talk about taking the next year to do this. They usually sign up before they get to their 2,500 hours, so the year of mentoring runs alongside their last hours of coaching.

We’ve got a year to grow and develop those skills, rather than trying to do this in three months.

Say you hold the PCC and you’re still some way short of 2,500 hours. When you sign up for MCC mentoring, we talk about the next year: time to work on your coaching skills between recordings, so each new recording shows what you’ve been learning. I treat the year as time for professional development.

How I plan MCC mentor coaching: 10 hours, all one-on-one; often five or six recordings, until three meet the MCC BARS; planned over about a year; usually start before 2,500 hours
My practice at MCC. ICF sets its own mentor coaching requirements; this is how I plan the mentoring.

What the MCC Level Asks of a Whole Coaching Session

What I’ll say about MCC-level coaching is short. At MCC there’s a higher level of listening, a higher level of attention to detail, a higher level of curiosity. And it’s meeting the MCC BARS, the bars that describe the coaching competencies at the MCC level.

I’m not going to describe a moment that showed MCC-level coaching. That’s not really a thing.

The whole coaching shows MCC or it doesn’t.

The question is whether there was a moment that met a bar or didn’t meet a bar, and that’s no different from the other levels. It’s just at the MCC level. ICF uses BARS at the ACC and MCC levels and the ICF PCC Markers at PCC, so the bar changes with the level. My written feedback stays aligned with the ICF Core Competencies, the same eight competencies behind every ICF level.

If you use the forms at MCC, the MCC Competency Review Form carries the same rule as the other levels: at least two-thirds (67%) of the skills in each competency must be demonstrated, and a skill counts when it’s rated Meets or Exceeds Standard in at least one observed coaching session. At MCC, the counts per competency are:

ICF Core CompetencyMCC: at least
3. Establishes and Maintains Agreements3 of 4 statements
4. Cultivates Trust and Safety3 of 4 statements
5. Maintains Presence3 of 4 statements
6. Listens Actively2 of 3 statements
7. Evokes Awareness2 of 3 statements
8. Facilitates Client Growth2 of 3 statements

Competency 2 isn’t rated from the session at MCC; in ICF credentialing it’s evaluated through the written exam. The PCC rule that some markers need more than one piece of evidence within a session has no MCC equivalent. And at every level, evidence for one statement can’t be added up across sessions, so a single recording has to show it.

Choosing an ICF Mentor Coach for MCC From 2027

ICF has said the MCC performance evaluation stays. The 2027 change to the portfolio pathway covers ACC and PCC only. ICF has also said that new mentor coaching at MCC after January 1, 2027 must be with a mentor coach who holds the ICF Mentor Coach Specialization (MCS) at MCC level, and that the Session Observation Forms and Competency Review Form aren’t required for MCC submission. ICF strongly encourages them as preparation for the performance evaluation.

The broader rule, as ICF has said it: from January 1, 2027, all new mentor coaching must be by an MCS holder at that level or above, renewals included, for any ICF coaching credential. ICF has said listings without the MCS come off its mentor coach registry at the end of 2026. There’s more on what ICF has said about MCC from 2027 in my article on the portfolio path.

ℹ
Note

If you need mentor coaching toward MCC, the MCS is the mentor coach qualification to check. ICF has said your mentor coach must hold the MCS at MCC level. A mentor coach holding the ICF MCS only at PCC level can’t take on your new MCC mentor coaching, and experienced mentor coaches who don’t hold it at all can’t either. Ask about your mentor coach’s MCS level before you sign up.

Alex Kudinov and I hold the MCS at all three levels, and every mentor coach on our team holds it at the level they mentor. Wherever you look to find a qualified mentor coach, check that the mentor coach holds the MCS at the level you’re working toward.

Where to Start If You’re Working Toward MCC

Start before you have your 2,500 hours, and give it the year. Our MCC package runs the way I’ve described here: 10 hours of mentor coaching for ICF credentialing, all one-on-one, with a mentor coach who holds the MCS at MCC level. If you compare it with another mentor coaching program, ask the same questions about format, recordings and the mentor’s MCS level.

If you mentor ACC and PCC coaches yourself, our mentor coach training program prepares mentor coaches for that work.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can MCC mentor coaching be done in a group?

Not in my practice. At MCC I do all 10 hours one-on-one, because you’re not going to get to the differences between PCC and MCC in a group mentoring session. ICF sets its own rules for how mentor coaching hours are delivered; the one-on-one format is my choice.

How many recordings does MCC mentor coaching take?

In my practice it generally takes more than three. I might review five or six recordings of your coaching conversations until three meet the MCC BARS.

When should I start MCC mentor coaching?

Coaches usually sign up with me before they reach 2,500 hours, and we plan the mentoring over about a year.

Who can mentor me toward MCC after January 1, 2027?

ICF has said new mentor coaching toward PCC or MCC must come from an MCS holder at that level or above. For MCC, that means a mentor coach who holds the MCS at MCC level.

Do I need the Session Observation Forms for my ICF application at MCC?

ICF has said the Session Observation Forms and Competency Review Form aren’t required for MCC submission. It strongly encourages them as preparation for the performance evaluation.

How do you prepare for mentor coaching?

Take group mentor coaching right after your coach training and start individual sessions once you coach real clients. Send one recording at a time, from a middle session that shows your coaching. Re-listen before each session and bring your own observations. Between sessions, coach as much as you can and work on one thing.

Advice for a workplace mentoring program tells a mentee to bring goals, questions and a short agenda to the first meeting with a mentor. That advice fits a mentorship program at work. Mentor coaching for an International Coaching Federation (ICF) credential asks for something more specific: recordings of your coaching, which a mentor coach reviews against the ICF Core Competencies at your level.

I sit on the other side of those recordings. I mentor coaches working toward the Associate Certified Coach (ACC) and Professional Certified Coach (PCC) credentials, including coaches renewing an ACC and coaches on the portfolio path. Your preparation decides how much each of your hours gives you. Below is what I ask of the coaches I mentor: when to start, what my agreement asks, which recordings to send, how to come ready, what to do between sessions, which forms to keep and what to ask a mentor coach after January 1, 2027.

Key Takeaways

  • Start group mentor coaching right after your training, and individual sessions once you are coaching real clients.
  • In my agreement, you send one recording at a time over no less than three months, 20 to 60 minutes long, with a transcript and a consent form.
  • Send a middle session that shows your coaching. Skip the first session and the one where the client talked the whole time.
  • Re-listen before each session and bring your own observations. Keep every Session Observation Form and Competency Review Form you receive.
  • After January 1, 2027, ask whether a mentor coach holds the Mentor Coach Specialization (MCS) at your level.

When to Start Mentor Coaching

Start group mentor coaching as soon as your coach training ends, and start individual mentor coaching once you are coaching real clients. Group sessions show you early what to improve. Individual sessions pay off when your recordings carry the challenges that real clients bring, which practice in class cannot give you.

Group Mentoring Right After Your Training Program

I think group mentor coaching is important to start immediately, right after your training. Finish the training first so you get the benefit of all that education, and then go straight into group mentoring. Before you go out into the world and get the rest of your hours, you will know what you need to improve on, and you will have time to work on it.

That order protects the experience you build next. In the time between however many hours you have now and however many you need, and before you start sending recordings for individual mentor coaching, you’ll be doing it right, not continuing to practice what’s wrong. That’s what I recommend, and it gets the whole engagement off on the right foot.

ICF sets hour rules for each part of mentor coaching. They are in our guide to group mentor coaching and individual sessions, so I won’t repeat them here. If you are renewing an ACC, the renewal rules are in our guide to mentor coaching for an ACC renewal.

Individual Sessions Once You Coach Real Clients

For individual mentor coaching, you need enough practice with real clients that you are experiencing the challenges of real clients. If you are only coaching other coaches or other students, in my view you are wasting your time.

Consider a coach who has only practiced with classmates. They might meet the competencies in their mentor coaching review. Then they get real clients and think, “This doesn’t work the way it worked in class.” It doesn’t, because they were practicing with somebody who was trained to be a client. Class builds your knowledge of the competencies. You need to work with real clients and meet real challenges while you have a mentor to help you figure out what those challenges are.

If you don’t have real clients yet, wait until you do. Who are you coaching right now, and would a mentor coach hear real challenges in those sessions?

What My Mentor Coaching Agreement Asks of You

Every mentor coaching engagement I take on starts with an agreement, and the logistics are part of it. As mentor and mentee, we agree how often we meet and over what time period: no less than three months. We agree on what I need from you for each recording. That gives us the same understanding, and then we just follow what we already agreed on.

I don’t want three recordings at one time, and I’m not going to accept that. We do one recording, and you get feedback. Then you spend a few weeks, or whatever it takes, practicing and working with clients. When you feel you’ve fully integrated that, you give me another recording, and we do the same thing again. It keeps the mentor relationship clear: we both know what happens next.

Three recordings spaced along a timeline, with several coaching sessions with clients between each one
One recording at a time. Between recordings, you coach your clients and practice the feedback.

For each recording, I ask for a session no shorter than 20 minutes and no longer than 60. The sweet spot is 40 to 45. I also need a clear transcript with timestamps, and a consent form. Those are my terms for what a mentee needs to send with each recording. ICF has said mentor coaching has no minimum or maximum session length, only that it is a full coaching session, and that the length is settled in the mentor coaching agreement.

I ask for 40 to 45 minutes because of what a short session does to a coach. When you have that little time, you spend a lot of it deciding what you’re not going to do. I’m not going to go deep into the coaching agreement, or into the client’s personal thing, because I don’t have time. A mentor coach can only give feedback on what the recording shows.

What should you look for in a mentor coach’s agreement? Our Mentor Coaching Foundations course asks new mentor coaches in training to draft one. In feedback on submissions to the English course (161 students, May to October 2026), the strongest agreements treated a recording as carrying duties to the coach and to the coach’s own client. They separated the time that counts toward the ten hours from preparation time, and they stated plainly that mentor coaching develops skill while ICF makes the credential decision.

The common gap was a uniform series of meetings. Of the first attempts sent back for revision on that assignment, 61% gave no session format: the sessions were scheduled, and nothing said how intake, regular and closing sessions would run. An agreement that names an intake, a feedback cycle built on recordings, and a closing review tells you what each session is for. Before you sign, also ask a mentor coach what happens if the evidence is not there by the end.

Which Recordings to Bring to a Mentoring Session

Bring a recording that lets your mentor coach see the competency, so I can give you feedback on whether it meets the competency. I think any session could be a useful recording. There are two I would skip: the session where the client did all the talking, and the first session with a new client.

Picture a session where the client was like a runaway train. You allowed them to talk and talk and talk the whole time, and you asked three questions. Even if that’s what the client needed, there’s no display of competency by you, because you only asked three questions. So don’t waste your mentoring on that.

Bring that session to the mentoring session as a question instead. You might say, “I’m having trouble with the coaching agreement. I want to focus on this, and this is what happened.” Or, “I’m having trouble interrupting. I had a client who talked the whole time, and I didn’t interrupt them when I should have.” Great. Let’s talk about that when we get to that marker. A problem you don’t know the answer to is one of the good questions to bring.

I would also say don’t bring the first session with your client. Bring the third, fourth, fifth or sixth session. The first session isn’t as much of the normal coaching. You are still setting goals and agreeing on what you will do together in the engagement, so it is a different type of conversation. By the third session the client has learned what coaching is. They know you, and you have built a bit of a relationship. That is your normal type of session, and that is what you want to bring.

If you are working toward PCC, read what a recording needs to show at PCC before you choose. Which of your recent sessions would let a mentor coach see the competency?

Before Each Meeting With Your Mentor Coach: Re-Listen and Come Prepared

Re-listen to the recording you sent shortly before each meeting with your mentor coach, so you know which session you turned in and you remember it. We are going to have a conversation about it. Come prepared with your own read of the session, and the discussion starts from your observations.

It’s not my job to remind you what you did.

What to Bring to Every Mentor Meeting

Come ready to talk about three things from the recording:

Those are your pre-feedback observations. Bring them to the first meeting with a mentor coach, and do the same before your next meeting and every one after it. Then come open to feedback on the parts you did not notice.

ICF’s Mentor Qualification Handbook lists reflection from the mentor coaching client on their demonstrated coaching skills and areas for further growth, alongside verbal and written feedback from the mentor coach about your strengths and development areas. Your observations are that reflection. Re-listening is also how you respect your mentor’s time and your own hours, because we spend the session on what you want to learn from the recording.

Between Sessions: What the Most Successful Mentees Do

What do my most successful mentees do between mentor coaching sessions? They coach a lot, and they focus on one thing they’re going to integrate into their coaching, taken from the feedback on their last recording. They keep practicing that one thing with their clients until it becomes part of how they coach naturally.

They coach, and they coach, and they coach.

Before a coaching session, one of them might think, “I want to make sure I bring curiosity.” Another might think, “I want to make sure I’m helping the client learn, and I’m going to integrate ways of helping the client learn throughout the session.” They are practicing the feedback until they figure out what feels natural and what works, so the skill becomes part of how they coach.

That practice is your side of a successful mentoring relationship, and it happens in your own client sessions. What is the one thing you want to develop in your coaching before your next recording?

Keep Your Session Observation Forms and Competency Review Form

Keep every Session Observation Form and every Competency Review Form your mentor coach gives you. ICF has said the coach being mentored is the sole holder of the forms, and if you lose your copies, it is not your mentor coach’s responsibility to produce them.

ICF’s Accreditation Alignment and Compliance Guide sets the minimum at three completed Session Observation Forms and one completed Competency Review Form. ICF has said the three Session Observation Forms come from three different recorded or live sessions, that there is no maximum, and that you receive a copy of every form completed, including any beyond the three.

Your mentor coach keeps a log of who they mentored and which Competency Review Form they issued, and ICF has said it emails mentor coaches to confirm they delivered the mentor coaching. On the portfolio path, ICF has said you submit only the Competency Review Form. A subset of applicants is asked by email to upload their Session Observation Forms, and ICF recommends uploading them up front. Store the forms with the rest of your credential information.

Questions to Ask Your Mentor Coach After January 1, 2027

From January 1, 2027, ICF has said all new mentor coaching must be with a mentor coach who holds the Mentor Coach Specialization at your level or above, including mentor coaching for renewals. Before you hire anyone, ask in your first conversation:

A mentor may not know yet. Not all mentors know ICF is changing the requirements, and some may be out there mentoring with no clue that they need an MCS. They’re not trying to do anything wrong. They just have no clue until someone asks, “Do you have an MCS?” and they say, “What’s an MCS?” So make sure your mentor coach knows ICF changed this and holds the MCS. Know your mentor coach’s level before you sign anything.

ICF has also given two more dates. Listings for mentor coaches without the MCS roll off ICF’s mentor coach registry after December 31, 2026. From April 1, 2027, ICF takes no new ACC or PCC portfolio applications that involve the performance evaluation. If you already have hours, ICF has said hours from a mentor coach without the MCS still count. Before you apply, you need three Session Observation Forms and one Competency Review Form from an MCS holder, which means a minimum of three more hours.

Those are the questions that changed. The full list of questions to ask a mentor coach, including confidentiality and what happens if the evidence is not there by the end, is in my article on the ICF portfolio path. Before you choose, read what separates a strong mentor coach from an eligible one.

Your next steps: choose your timing, pick your first recording and ask your questions before you sign. Alex Kudinov and I hold the MCS at all three levels, and every mentor coach on our team holds it at the level they mentor. If you want to work with us, start with our mentor coaching for ICF credentials. If you plan to mentor coaches yourself one day, see how Tandem trains its mentor coaches.

Questions About Preparing for Mentor Coaching

How is mentor coaching different from a workplace mentorship program?

A workplace mentorship program pairs a mentee with a more experienced colleague for advice and career conversations. Mentor coaching for an ICF credential works from recordings of your coaching. A mentor coach observes your sessions, gives verbal and written feedback against the ICF Core Competencies at your level, and completes the Session Observation Forms and the Competency Review Form that ICF asks for.

Can I use a recording of a classmate or another coach?

I recommend real clients. A classmate or another student was trained to be a client, so the session doesn’t show the challenges real clients bring. You might meet the competencies in review and still find that coaching real clients doesn’t work the way it worked in class. If you don’t have real clients yet, wait until you do.

How long should a mentor coaching recording be?

ICF has said there is no minimum or maximum length, as long as it is a full coaching session, and that the length is settled in your mentor coaching agreement. In my agreement, I ask for 20 to 60 minutes, and the sweet spot is 40 to 45.

Can I send all my recordings at once?

Not to me. My agreement runs over no less than three months, one recording at a time. You get feedback, practice with clients for a few weeks, and send the next recording once you have integrated the feedback.

Who keeps the Session Observation Forms?

You do. ICF has said the coach being mentored is the sole holder of the Session Observation Forms and the Competency Review Form. Your mentor coach keeps a log, and if you lose your copies, it is not your mentor coach’s responsibility to produce them.

What does it mean if you’re not ready for your ICF credential?

It means the forms from your mentor coach show there was not yet enough evidence that one or more ICF competencies were demonstrated in your observed coaching sessions. In my experience the gap is usually the coaching agreement or Competency 8, Facilitates Client Growth. Then you practice those skills and bring another recording, and we review the evidence together.

You have finished your coach training, you have done your mentor coaching, and your mentor coach tells you the recordings do not yet show enough evidence for your International Coaching Federation (ICF) credential. Or you are the mentor coach, and you are the one who has to say it. Either way, the words that land are “not ready,” and they can sound like a verdict on you as a coach.

I mentor coaches toward their ICF credentials, and I train the mentor coaches who complete the forms behind an ICF coaching credential. From the mentor coach’s side, this conversation is about evidence. The rules below apply across the three credentials, Associate Certified Coach (ACC), Professional Certified Coach (PCC) and Master Certified Coach (MCC), and I point out where a level differs. I cover what the form shows and where the gap usually is, then how the conversation goes, where my job ends and what happens if you are still not ready at the end.

Key Takeaways

  • “Not ready” means the forms show there was not yet enough evidence that a competency was demonstrated. It describes what a recording showed.
  • A skill counts once it is demonstrated at a competent level in one observed session, and each competency needs at least two-thirds of its skills.
  • In my experience the gap is usually the coaching agreement or Competency 8, Facilitates Client Growth, and really rarely anything else.
  • The plan is practice, another recording and another review. ICF’s own guidance expects that additional sessions and forms may be needed.
  • A mentor coach refines what your training taught. Teaching the basics is the school’s job, and a struggle such as being triggered belongs in supervision.

What the Form Shows When You Are Not Ready

By the time we talk about it, the evidence is already on the form. The data adds up: there was enough evidence to say a competency (or a marker or a bar) was demonstrated, or there wasn’t. So it’s a data conversation, and readiness is a reading of that evidence for each competency in turn.

The math is the rule printed on ICF’s Competency Review Form, and the same rule appears on the form for every ICF credential. A skill counts as demonstrated when it is rated at a competent level in at least one observed session. A competency needs at least two-thirds (67%) of its skills demonstrated, and the two-thirds is counted inside each competency. The number of skills in each competency differs by level, so the threshold for one competency at ACC is not the same count as at PCC.

ICF publishes the Core Competencies, and each level observes them in its own way: the ACC BARS (Behaviorally Anchored Rating Scales) at ACC, the PCC Markers at PCC and the MCC BARS at MCC. ICF’s Accreditation Alignment and Compliance Guide asks for at least three Session Observation Forms and one Competency Review Form demonstrating at least 67% proficiency in all competency areas. You can see how those forms are laid out in the free forms Tandem publishes for each level, and our page on what ICF asks for at PCC covers the rest of that application.

The form reads what you did in one recording against the ICF Core Competencies and the ICF standards for your level. Your coaching hours do not appear on it, and neither do your years of coaching experience. A life coach and a coach who works in leadership coaching are observed the same way. What counts is whether each core competency shows up in the session.

Either the math works or it doesn’t.

Coaching Ethics and Coaching Mindset Sit Outside the Count

Two of the eight competencies work differently, so it helps to know them before you read your form. Competency 1, Demonstrates Ethical Practice, is a gate checked yes or no. It is not scored by markers or bars, and strength elsewhere cannot make up for it. If you are unsure what ethical practice asks of you, the ICF Code of Ethics is the place to read.

Competency 2, Embodies a Coaching Mindset, is not rated from the session at ACC or MCC. It is evaluated when you take the ICF Credentialing Exam, the written part of credentialing. ICF has said Competency 2 is not scored at PCC either. So at ACC, PCC and MCC alike, the two-thirds count runs across Competencies 3 to 8.

Where the Gap Usually Is: The Coaching Agreement or Competency 8

In my experience, when a coach is not ready, it’s usually one of two things. They didn’t do the coaching agreement, or they didn’t do Competency 8: the learning, the progress and the next steps. It’s really rarely anything else. There might be a marker or a bar, but for the most part they get those, especially after three sessions, when we’ve closed the gaps.

The coaching agreement is Competency 3, Establishes and Maintains Agreements. It is where the client and the coach settle what the session is for, what success would look like and which of the client’s coaching goals this conversation serves. When none of that is in the recording, the rest of the session has nothing to build on.

At PCC the effect is written into the guidance. In the ICF PCC Markers, marker 3.1 establishes the session goal, and if 3.1 is not observed, markers 3.2, 3.3 and 3.4 cannot be demonstrated either. Competency 3 has four markers at PCC and needs three of them, so a missing session goal leaves the whole competency short.

Competency 8, Facilitates Client Growth, covers the learning, the progress and the next steps. If the recording never gets to what the client learned and what they will do next, the form has no evidence of it, however strong the middle of the session was.

How the Conversation Goes: The Form, the Disappointment, the Plan

It happens when we review a recording together and go over the feedback. We look at the form, and the data is there. The coach can see which competencies had enough evidence and which did not, and what was missing from the session. It’s clear on the form.

They are disappointed, because they went through training, they went through mentoring and they’re not going to get their credential this time. ICF makes the credential decision. My forms record the evidence. So we talk about how to resolve it.

A mentor coaching review table with a recorded session on a laptop, a shared form with highlighted marks and a notebook leading to a fresh form
Review, practice, record again. The form shows where the evidence is missing, and the next recording shows whether the gap has closed.

What needs to be resolved, and what do you need to focus on, learn and practice to build competency so you’re ready? Then you go practice that. When you’ve figured it out, you do another recording and we review it to see whether you’ve closed the gap. It just is what it is.

ICF expects this to happen sometimes. Its Accreditation Alignment and Compliance Guide says that when the 67% is not met, “additional mentor coaching sessions, and therefore additional mentor coaching observation forms, may be needed.” ICF has said there is no maximum number of forms, and that you receive a copy of every form your mentor coach completes. Before you plan extra sessions, read the ICF mentor coaching requirements for your level.

I did have one person get really mad one time, but that was a one-off.

Where ICF Level 1 and Level 2 Coach Training Ends and Mentor Coaching Begins

The coach training school’s job is to teach you to coach according to the BARS and the markers, the competencies ICF has put around each level of coaching. It teaches you, gives you feedback and lets you practice in an environment where you can get it wrong, learn and get feedback again.

That holds whatever your coaching education looked like. It might be an ICF Level 2 program, a Level 1 program, one of the other coaching programs with ICF accreditation, or courses from several places that were not all ICF accredited. An ICF-accredited coach training program and a patchwork of courses have the same job here: teaching you the ICF Core Competencies and Code of Ethics, and giving you practice with feedback.

When you get to the end and get to mentor coaching, my job is different. It’s the mentor coach’s job to help you refine those skills and competencies, and to close any gaps that have you below the competency level you want to get credentialed at. It’s not the mentor coach’s job to teach you what the school didn’t.

I’m helping them elevate what they’ve already learned. I’m not teaching them what they don’t know or what they weren’t taught.

ICF names this work in its Mentor Coaching Competencies. One of the six is Conducts Formative Appraisals, which evaluates the degree to which the mentor coaching client’s coaching aligns with the ICF Core Competencies. It assumes the coaching is already there to appraise. The coaching profession needs both jobs, the teaching and the refining, and they belong to different people.

When the Conversation Belongs in Supervision

I’m also not your supervisor. We may have a short conversation about what your struggle was, but it’s the struggle to meet the competency. Say a coach tells me, “Well, I was triggered, and I kept wanting to tell the client what to do.” Great. That’s a perfect conversation to have with a supervisor.

Mentor coaching stays with the competencies in the recording, and the trigger behind them is a conversation for supervision. Our article on where supervision and mentor coaching part ways covers the difference in more depth.

When a Coach Can’t Yet Do a Coaching Agreement

Sometimes the gap is bigger than refinement. A coach arrives for mentor coaching and cannot yet do a coaching agreement at all. When that happens, we go over the facts. If a school has sent them to me, I go back to the school with those facts.

I ask the school what happened. Have you given this coach feedback in class? Why don’t they know how to do a coaching agreement? The school needs to know, so it can refine its practices, and so coaches aren’t reaching a mentor coach without a skill their training was there to teach.

I can’t speak for how other schools run their classes. What I hold to is that the only way to build competency is to do it and get feedback on it. A coach who arrives without a coaching agreement needs more of that practice, and the place for it is coach training, before mentor coaching starts.

What the Mentor Coaching Agreement Settles Before the First Recording

A lot of what makes a not-ready conversation workable is decided before the first recording, in the mentor coaching agreement. We agree on what mentor coaching is and what the process is. We also agree on the things you already know you’re uncomfortable with, and the things you know you’re struggling with, that we need to focus on.

So we’re clear on the way we’re going to work together and what is needed, and then we just follow what we’ve already agreed on. When a recording later shows a gap, we are working inside a process we both agreed to.

ICF treats this as a competency of its own. The second of its six Mentor Coaching Competencies is Establishes and Maintains Mentor Coaching Agreements, which begins: “Partners with the mentor coaching client to create clear agreements about the mentor coaching…” The agreement also covers practical terms, such as what you send for each review, how the recordings are spaced and your mentor coach’s policy on extra sessions. Those are worth settling before you start.

If You Are Not Ready by the End of Mentor Coaching

If you aren’t ready by the end, you need to keep practicing until you’ve incorporated all the skills at the competency level you want for your credential. The plan stays the same when the planned sessions run out: focus, practice, another recording, another review.

On the portfolio path, the paperwork shows it. ICF has said that on the portfolio application path you submit only the Competency Review Form, and a subset of applications is audited for the Session Observation Forms behind it. If the evidence isn’t there, the Competency Review Form records that. I have written separately about what that form records when the evidence is not there yet.

If you were mentored to apply for a higher-level credential and the evidence isn’t there at that level, there is another route. ICF has said the evaluation can be redone at the lower level, and the same recordings can be reused, as long as your mentor coach holds the Mentor Coach Specialization at that lower level too. So a coach mentored toward PCC can be evaluated for ACC from the same sessions.

One date matters here as well. ICF has said that from April 1, 2027, new ACC and PCC portfolio applications no longer involve the recorded performance evaluation, which puts the evidence for those applications on the mentor coach’s forms.

If you are a mentor coach, or training to become one, this is the conversation you are preparing for: reading the evidence, saying plainly what the form shows, staying inside your role and agreeing up front on how you will work. It is a skill, and it can be learned. Our full training program for mentor coaches is a 71-hour live cohort I lead, accredited under ICF’s Advanced Accreditation in Mentor Coaching. Our guide to the ICF Mentor Coach Specialization explains what the specialization requires at each level.

Frequently Asked Questions About Not Being Ready

Can I still become ICF certified if my mentor coach says I’m not ready?

You will hear it called ICF certification. ICF calls its coaching certification a credential, and ICF makes the credential decision, while your mentor coach records the evidence. On the portfolio path, ICF has said you submit only the Competency Review Form with your application, so if the form shows the evidence is not there yet, keep practicing and bring another recording before you apply.

If I was mentored toward PCC, can I apply for the ACC credential instead?

ICF has said yes. If a coach does not show enough evidence at the higher level, the evaluation is redone at the lower level and the same recordings can be reused. The mentor coach has to hold the Mentor Coach Specialization at the ICF ACC level to complete ACC forms. Holding it at PCC alone is not enough.

How many extra mentor coaching sessions does the International Coaching Federation allow?

ICF has said there is no maximum number of forms, and that you receive a copy of every one. The minimum is three Session Observation Forms and one Competency Review Form, and ICF’s guidance says additional sessions and forms may be needed when the 67% is not met. How many extra sessions you have, and on what terms, is something you and your mentor coach agree.

Is it my mentor coach’s job to teach what my ICF-accredited training did not?

Teaching you to coach to the BARS and the markers is the school’s job, whether you trained in a Level 1 or Level 2 program or somewhere else. My job as a mentor coach is to help you refine what you learned and close the gaps that keep you below the level you want. If the gap is a basic skill such as the coaching agreement, and a school sent you to me, I go back to that school.

What happens in a group mentor coaching session?

In a group mentor coaching session, one person coaches and one is the client while the others observe. Before the coaching, the coach names what they want feedback on. Afterward the coach speaks first. The observers share what made them curious. The mentor coach goes last and leaves the coach with one competency to work on.

“We decide who’s going to be the coach and who’s going to be the client.” That’s how a group mentor coaching session starts when I run one, and everything after it follows an order.

Group mentor coaching is one of the ways coaches working toward an International Coaching Federation (ICF) credential get their mentor coaching. One person coaches and another is the client. The rest of the group observes, with a mentor coach in the room. Below is the order I run it in, from choosing roles to the one thing the coach takes away, with the questions I ask each person along the way.

Key Takeaways

  • Before the coaching starts, the coach names the areas they want the group to listen for, and the feedback starts there.
  • Feedback runs in a fixed order. The coach speaks first and the mentor coach goes last, with the observers in between.
  • Observers share what made them curious and what they learned, so the whole group learns from one person’s coaching.
  • Live feedback in a group is a set of things the mentor coach noticed. A detailed review of a recording happens one-on-one.
  • The coach leaves with one digestible chunk to work on, such as asking about the client’s learning and progress.

Three Seats in a Group Mentor Coaching Session

A group mentor coaching session has three seats: the coach, the client and the observers, and each one is a place to learn. As I put it, “You learn from being a coach, you learn from being a client, and you learn from being an observer.” The goal is that everybody’s learning, whichever seat they’re in.

ICF’s own list of Mentor Coaching Competencies has one for this work, Manages Group Mentor Coaching: “Effectively manages the group mentor coaching process.” ICF names the competency. It doesn’t prescribe a format, so the running order below is my practice. If you’re an ICF mentor coach who runs group sessions, or a coach about to join one, it shows what happens in the room.

You don’t need your own coaching to be observed or recorded that day to build your coaching skills in a group. The observer seat has its own work to do, and I ask observers for it directly after the coach has spoken.

Six steps of a group mentor coaching session in order: pick the coach and the client and ask what to listen for, the coaching session, the coach speaks first, observers share what made them curious, the mentor coach goes last, one chunk to work on
The running order. Roles and a focus first, then the coaching, then feedback from the coach, the observers and the mentor coach, in that order.

Before the Coaching: Roles and What to Listen For

Before the coaching starts, two things happen. We decide who will be the coach and who will be the client. Then I ask the coach what they want the group to listen for, so the feedback afterward is about the areas where they’re trying to grow as a coach right now.

The question I ask the coach is this: “Are there any specific areas you’re trying to grow in, that you want us to listen for and give you specific feedback on?”

Whatever the coach names becomes the first thing we talk about later. Then they do the coaching session.

During the Coaching: What the Mentor Coach and the Observers Listen For

During the coaching, the mentor coach and the observers listen for different things. I’m doing fairly detailed feedback against ICF’s standard for the ICF credential level the coach is working at. The observers listen mostly for what they were taught in class: are you asking open-ended questions, and did the coaching agreement get met?

For a coach pursuing ACC, the Associate Certified Coach credential, that standard is the ACC Behaviorally Anchored Rating Scales (BARS). For a coach working at the Professional Certified Coach (PCC) level, it’s the PCC Markers. Which one I use depends on where the coach is and what level they’re working at. Either way, the feedback stays in alignment with the ICF Core Competencies at that level.

The observers listen for the BARS and markers to the extent they know them. What they’re really listening for is what they learned in their coach training. They aren’t thinking about whether the coach met all the BARS and markers. They’re thinking, “Are you doing what we learned how to do?”

The Coach Speaks First

When the coaching ends, we call everybody back. The first person I go to is the coach. Before the coach can receive feedback from anyone else, they give their own view of how they think they did and what they would change. I ask them questions like these.

The coach’s own view of the session comes before anyone else’s. ICF lists the mentoring client’s reflection on their demonstrated coaching skills and areas for further growth as a required element of mentor coaching.

A coach who is used to reflecting on their own coaching usually has a lot to say here. A coach who isn’t gets practice every time they sit in this seat.

What Observers Share: Curiosity and Questions

After the coach, everybody else goes around, or volunteers. I don’t ask observers to rate the coaching. I ask what they noticed that made them curious and what they learned. I also ask what would be worth talking about as a group, so that the whole group learns from one person’s coaching.

These are the questions I ask the observers:

I’m not asking them to judge whether it met the standard, because the goal is that everybody’s learning. By talking about what they saw and having a discussion about it, they’re all learning from the coaching.

The observer seat is easy to underuse. In our Mentor Coaching Foundations course, one assignment asks students to design a group mentor coaching session. In feedback on those submissions (the English course, 161 students, May to October 2026), 12 growth notes on designs that were accepted pointed to the same thing: inclusion plans that keep observers busy without saying what each one gains.

One way to name what an observer gains is the question “What did you learn that you’re not doing?” There’s more on what trips up students designing a group session in our piece on mentor coaching mistakes.

The Mentor Coach Goes Last: Live Feedback and Its Limits

As the facilitator, I generally go last and review what I saw. In a group session I’m doing it live, so I caught what I could catch. I don’t do timestamps, and I don’t take notes on the behavior, because there’s no time for that live. It’s just, “Hey, you said this, and this was this competency.”

I usually turn on transcription, so I’m pulling things out of the transcript and pasting them on my form, because that makes it a little easier.

Then I give the disclosure: “This is not a full-blown assessment. These are just some things I noticed, some helpful feedback, to help you see in the big picture where you are.”

Live mentor coach feedback is a different thing from the review I do on coaching recordings. With recorded sessions, I can stop the recording, mark where each piece of evidence is and describe the behavior beside it. That written feedback goes into far more detail than anything I can catch in the room, and a full review of recorded coaching sessions belongs in individual mentoring.

We’re really just catching what we saw and what we were able to capture when we can’t hit pause.

The broader skill set a good mentor coach brings to all of this is in my piece on what a mentor coach has to be able to do.

Start With the Coach’s Focus, Then Open It to the Group

My feedback starts where the coach asked for it. If the coach said they were specifically focusing on the coaching agreement, then we go to the coaching agreement first. What were your concerns about it? Did you do it? What was strong, what did you miss, and how could you cover that next time?

Then the group gets involved. We might have a discussion about how that would look. What could you ask? Where could you have asked it?

After the coach’s focus area, I go over everything else the same way. Some of that depends on how much time we actually have.

One Digestible Chunk Instead of Nine Markers

I close by giving the coach the big picture and one thing to work on. I’ll say something like, “It looks like you’re naturally meeting these four, five, six competencies. Those things are happening naturally, so don’t give any energy to them. Just let them happen.” Then I name the area where the energy should go.

For example, Competency 8. Maybe the coach didn’t cover it well or enough, or missed it completely. In the ICF Core Competencies, Competency 8 is Facilitates Client Growth. At the PCC level it has nine markers, and six of them have to be demonstrated. In the ACC-level BARS it has three statements, and two have to be demonstrated.

That’s how ICF counts a competency: at least two-thirds of its skills, each one demonstrated at a competent level in at least one observed session. Nine markers is still a lot to hand someone at the end of a group session.

I’m not going to tell them, “There are nine markers there. You need to do them all.” Those markers bunch up. There are several about learning and progress, and then several about next steps. So I bunch learning and progress together: in the next couple of sessions you do, really make it a point to ask what progress the client made, what they learned and how they’re going to apply that learning. You can do it throughout the session or at the end of the session. It doesn’t matter.

Or I might send them to the actions, to get deeper into them. The questions go past what the client is going to do. How are you going to do it? What do you expect to learn from it? What are your barriers? What might get in the way? What support do you need? Those questions help the client build a plan for how they’re going to be successful between sessions.

So the mentee leaves with one little chunk to work on, so they can start to integrate it. I pick the most valuable thing they can fix and let them work on improving that.

They can’t fix everything, and they don’t need to fix everything at once.

If you run group sessions, try this with the next coach you observe. Of all the coaching competencies you saw, which one chunk would you leave them with?

Bring Your Hardest Problems to Group

If you’re the coach in a group, bring your hardest problems from your coaching practice. Across your mentor coaching, before anyone reviews a recording of yours, bring all your hardest stuff and all your problems, and get those resolved. That’s a great thing to do in group mentor coaching, and a great thing to do in class.

The review of a recording happens in individual mentor coaching sessions, and those one-on-one sessions ask for different preparation. I recommend doing group mentor coaching right after your training, before you go out and get the rest of your hours, so you know early what you need to improve. When to start, and how to prepare for the individual sessions, is a topic of its own.

Group mentor coaching is something I run for coaches working toward ACC and PCC. When a coach is working toward the Master Certified Coach (MCC) level, my mentoring is all one-on-one. I don’t run a group for the MCC credential.

Whichever mentor coaching program you choose, the rules on how group and individual mentor coaching count toward the mentor coaching requirement are in our guide to ICF mentor coaching. If you’d rather work with a mentor in a group, our mentor coaching for ICF credentials includes group sessions.

If you mentor coaches, or want to, running a group session like this is a skill you can learn, and ICF counts it as a mentor coaching competency of its own. Our overview of the ICF Mentor Coach Specialization (MCS) sets out what it requires at each level. In Tandem’s Mentor Coach Specialization training program, each participant facilitates a faculty-observed group mentor coaching round and gets live feedback in class. Alex Kudinov and I hold the MCS at all three levels, and every mentor coach on our team holds it at the level they mentor.

Questions About Group Mentor Coaching Sessions

What do observers do in a group mentor coaching session?

They listen for what they were taught in class, such as open-ended questions and whether the coaching agreement got met, and for the BARS and markers to the extent they know them. After the coach speaks, they share what made them curious and what they learned, without judging whether the coaching met the standard.

Who gives feedback first in a group mentor coaching session?

In the group mentor coaching sessions I run, the coach goes first with their own view of how they did. The observers go next, and I generally go last as the mentor coach, starting with whatever the coach asked the group to listen for.

Is the mentor coach’s live feedback a full assessment?

Live feedback in a group session is not a full assessment. I catch what I can catch, without timestamps or notes on the behavior, and I say so: “This is not a full-blown assessment.” A detailed review of recorded coaching sessions happens one-on-one.

Who can lead mentor coaching after January 1, 2027?

ICF has said that from January 1, 2027, all new mentor coaching, including mentor coaching for renewals, must come from an MCS holder at that level or above. In other words, your mentor coach must hold the MCS at your level or above, whether you’re going for ACC, PCC or MCC. That rule touches ICF credentialing at every level.

What is the difference between ACC and PCC coaching?

ACC and PCC coaching are judged against two different ICF standards: the ACC BARS and the PCC Markers. Both levels require two-thirds of the skills in each competency, but the counts and the evidence rules differ. From a mentor coach’s chair, PCC coaching usually goes deeper, with more exploration and more focus on the person.

I’m Cherie Silas, a Master Certified Coach (MCC) with the International Coaching Federation (ICF), and I train mentor coaches at Tandem Coaching Academy, the coach education side of our company. We sell that training, which you should know before you read on.

When I review a recording, the difference between Associate Certified Coach (ACC) and Professional Certified Coach (PCC) coaching comes down to the document I’m listening against. How I listen is in the ACC BARS (Behaviorally Anchored Rating Scales) or the PCC Markers. That’s what I’m listening for, and that is the distinction.

So that’s where I’ll start: what each of the two ICF coaching credentials asks for in a session, what I hear when a coach is working toward ACC or PCC, and the two misjudgments I see from the mentor’s chair. One belongs to mentors, and one belongs to the coaches they mentor.

Key Takeaways

  • ACC coaching is heard against the ACC BARS and PCC coaching against the PCC Markers: two documents, with different counts per competency.
  • Both levels need at least two-thirds of the skills in each competency, shown in at least one observed session. At PCC, 18 markers need more than one clear piece of evidence within a single session.
  • Competency 1, ethics, is a yes or no gate at both levels, and Competency 2 is never tallied by a mentor coach.
  • Mentors who coach at PCC level can hear PCC-level misses in an ACC session, so each missed opportunity has to be checked against the ACC BARS.
  • In my experience, coaches usually think they did worse than the recording shows; the competency is much wider than asking questions.

ACC and PCC Coaching Answer to Two Different Standards

ACC and PCC coaching are heard against two different documents: ACC coaching against the ACC BARS, PCC coaching against the PCC Markers. PCC is a whole different set of requirements. What demonstrates PCC is meeting those markers and the competencies, and that’s very different from ACC. It’s a different standard.

Some things are shared. At both levels, ICF asks for at least two-thirds (67%) of the skills in each competency to be demonstrated at a competent level. The line is drawn per competency, so a strong competency can’t make up for a weak one. A skill counts as demonstrated when it shows up at a competent level in at least one observed coaching session. ICF credentialing treats ACC and PCC as two professional standards, each with its own statements and its own Competency Review Form, and that is how a mentor coach has to hear them.

I also explain the depth through experience. Look at the hours: the ICF ACC credential requires 100 hours of coaching experience, and the PCC credential requires 500 hours. That’s five times more experience than an ACC coach, and five times more experience should translate into a deeper level of coaching. When a coach moves from ACC to PCC, the hours go up and the standard changes with them. The inference from hours to depth is my own reading.

Everything else about ICF coach certification lives in other posts on our site. The ICF ACC requirements and ICF PCC requirements posts walk through the ICF certification process. The hours are there: coach training hours and the hours of coaching education, then mentor coaching hours and the 500 coaching hours, with how many of them must be paid. So are the steps of an ACC application or PCC application. If you already hold a credential, see how ACC and PCC renewal differ. Here I stay with the coaching itself.

What the ACC BARS and the PCC Markers Ask For at Each Level

The ACC BARS and the PCC Markers both sit on the eight ICF Core Competencies, and both look for the ability to apply the ICF Core Competencies in a recorded coaching session. They part ways in the statements under each of the coaching competencies, in how many of those statements a coach needs, and in the evidence rules. Here is the count for each competency, from ICF’s Competency Review Forms, with the two levels kept apart.

ICF Core CompetencyACC BARS: statements neededPCC Markers: markers needed
3. Establishes and Maintains Agreements3 of 43 of 4
4. Cultivates Trust and Safety2 of 33 of 4
5. Maintains Presence3 of 44 of 5
6. Listens Actively2 of 35 of 7
7. Evokes Awareness2 of 36 of 8
8. Facilitates Client Growth2 of 36 of 9

Read down the two columns and the shape changes. At ACC, four of the six competencies need two statements out of three. At PCC, Listens Actively, Evokes Awareness and Facilitates Client Growth each carry seven to nine markers, and a coach needs five or six of them. Competencies 1 and 2 aren’t in the table, because neither is counted this way.

Then come the evidence rules. At PCC, 18 markers need more than one clear piece of evidence before they can be marked, including all eight markers in Evokes Awareness. That evidence has to come from inside one session: ICF has said evidence for a marker can’t be added up across sessions. The ACC BARS have no equivalent rule. The PCC Markers also chain Competency 3 together. If marker 3.1, which establishes the session goal, isn’t observed, markers 3.2, 3.3 and 3.4 can’t be observed either. The ACC BARS have a rule of their own: if a statement includes “and,” both parts must be present to meet the standard.

Ethics works the same way at both levels. Competency 1, Demonstrates Ethical Practice, is a yes or no gate, and strength elsewhere can’t offset it. Competency 2, Embodies a Coaching Mindset, isn’t rated from the session at ACC; the written ICF credentialing exam evaluates it. At PCC it shows up through 11 markers borrowed from other competencies, and ICF has said Competency 2 is not scored. Either way, a mentor coach has nothing to tally for it.

MCC is a third standard, with its own BARS and its own count per competency. At MCC level, an MCC coach is heard against that third document. Mentoring toward the MCC credential is a different conversation, and I’m leaving it for another article.

Two-column card comparing the ACC BARS and the PCC Markers: both need two-thirds of the skills in each competency; ACC statements with and need both parts and Competency 2 is assessed in the credentialing exam; at PCC, 18 markers need more than one clear piece of evidence in the session, marker 3.1 gates 3.2 to 3.4 and Competency 2 is shown through 11 markers; at both levels Competency 1 is a yes or no gate
Two standards, side by side. The same two-thirds line, with evidence rules that differ by level.

What I Listen For: Surface and Problem, or Depth and Person

If you ask me what the difference sounds like, the only thing I could say is that ACC could be more at a surface level, more focused on the problem. Could be. PCC is going to go deeper, and it’s going to focus more on exploration and more on the person, not the problem they’re trying to solve.

I hold that loosely. It describes where a session’s attention tends to sit, and the standard itself is in the documents above.

Our own course data shows how differently people learning this work hear the same recording. In the feedback on submissions to Tandem’s Mentor Coaching Foundations course (161 students in the English course, May to October 2026), every student analyzes the same 25-minute recording, which the course presents as a PCC-level demonstration, and names the competencies they heard as strengths and as gaps. Across 132 first attempts, Establishes and Maintains Agreements was named as a strength 119 times (90%) and as a gap 19 times. Evokes Awareness was named as a strength 113 times (86%) and as a gap 78 times (59%), more often than any other competency.

The story behind those readings is in how students heard one 25-minute recording.

If you’re reviewing your own recording, try one question at the moments where you followed the client’s problem closely: would exploring the person have changed what the session shows?

One Behavior That Can Clear Eight Misses

When I go through a recording with a coach, a lot of times it’s this: if you just focus on the person, it’s going to clear up these eight things you missed in this recording. It’s one behavior: focus on the person.

You don’t have to say something to meet this, this and this. That’s why the conversation around behaviors is important.

Picture a coach reading feedback with eight separate gaps on it. “Focus on the person” is one thing to carry into the next recording, and the next review shows whether those gaps closed.

When Mentors Who Coach at PCC Level Review an ACC Session

The gap between the two standards shows up on the mentor’s side too. In the Mentor Coach Specialization (MCS) training I teach, I find mentors in training are often citing missed opportunities on ACC recordings, but the missed opportunity they’re describing is at the PCC level, not the ACC level. They’re having a hard time separating the way they coach, at the level they coach at, from the expectation of ACC.

They’re looking at an ACC session and basing it on what they know PCC to be, even though they may not know the markers yet, because they coach at a PCC level. So their expectations may be higher than the level they’re reviewing. That’s something else we have to calibrate on.

These are experienced coaches, and that is why it happens: they hear the session through their own coaching. The missed opportunity they name may be real at their own level and still be no gap against the ACC BARS. So before a moment goes on the Session Observation Form as a missed opportunity, check it against the ACC BARS.

Their expectations may be higher than the level they’re reviewing.

Familiarity plays a part too. The participants who had mentored before knew the PCC Markers, because that was the standard they had mentored against, and they actually had more trouble assessing against the ACC BARS than against the PCC Markers.

Almost all of the participants in my first cohort had never seen the ACC BARS, which I wrote about in my piece on what makes a good mentor coach.

A mentor coach reviews against the standard for the level the coach is working toward, whatever level the mentor coaches at, PCC or MCC. The ICF rules behind that are in what ICF requires of mentor coaching. That’s why calibrating on both documents is part of how we train mentor coaches.

Why Coaches Often Think They Coached Worse Than They Did

The opposite mismatch happens on the coach’s side. Coaches often think, “I can’t do anything but ask questions,” or “I did too much,” or “I was leading.” And really, they’re showing a higher level of skill than they think.

It’s natural. But they’ve locked themselves into “I’m a coach, I can only ask questions,” and they don’t realize that the competency is much wider than that. That’s usually where the mismatch comes in. They usually think they’re doing much worse than they are.

They usually think they’re doing much worse than they are.

Say a professional coach finishes a session and thinks, “I did too much.” The recording shows whether they did too much, or whether they used the wider range the competency allows. Your coaching skills may be wider than the picture you’re holding of them, and the recording, heard against the right standard, settles it.

So when you debrief your own session, ask where “I did too much” comes from. Did you hear it on the recording, or did you expect more from yourself? And which standard are you reading your own coaching against? If you’re an ICF coach working toward ACC or PCC and want someone else to hear it, that’s what our mentor coaching for ICF credentials is for.

Mentored at One Level, Applying at Another

The two standards also matter when the level of the mentoring and the level of the application differ. ICF has said, in a live call with ICF Credentials and Standards staff in August 2026, that a coach may be mentored above the level they are applying for. The mentor coach has to hold the MCS at the level being delivered, and the two-thirds line has to be met at that level. A PCC-level MCS holder can’t complete ACC-level forms without also holding the ACC MCS.

If the evidence isn’t there at the higher level, ICF has said the evaluation is redone at the lower level, and the same recordings can be reused. Each evaluation uses its own standard and that level’s Session Observation Form and Competency Review Form. The post on the ICF portfolio path covers what this means before a credential application goes in.

So on the way to earning an ICF credential, ask your mentor coach which levels they hold the MCS at. Alex Kudinov and I hold the MCS at all three levels, and every mentor coach on our team holds it at the level they mentor.

If mentoring is the next step in your coaching career, hearing each level against its own standard is a trained skill. Tandem’s Mentor Coach Specialization training program trains mentor coaches on both the ACC BARS and the PCC Markers, and it is accredited under ICF’s Advanced Accreditation in Mentor Coaching. For what the specialization asks at each level, start with the ICF Mentor Coach Specialization.

Questions About ACC and PCC Coaching

Is PCC coaching just ACC coaching with more hours?

PCC asks for more hours, and it is also a different standard. ACC coaching is heard against the ACC BARS and PCC coaching against the PCC Markers, with different counts per competency and evidence rules that apply only at PCC, such as the 18 markers that need more than one clear piece of evidence in a single session.

Do ACC and PCC use the same two-thirds rule?

At both levels, at least two-thirds of the skills in each competency must be demonstrated, and a skill counts when it shows up at a competent level in at least one of the observed coaching sessions. The number of skills in each competency is set separately at ACC, PCC or MCC: Listens Actively, for example, needs 2 of 3 at ACC and 5 of 7 at PCC.

Can I be mentored at PCC level and still apply for ACC?

ICF has said yes. A coach may be mentored above the level they apply for, as long as the mentor coach holds the MCS at that level. If there isn’t enough evidence at PCC level, the evaluation is redone at ACC level with the same recordings.

Why does my recording sound weaker to me than to my mentor coach?

In my experience, coaches usually think they’re doing much worse than they are. They lock themselves into “I can only ask questions,” when the competency is much wider than that. The recording, heard against the standard for your level, shows what was there.

What is mentor coach calibration?

Mentor coach calibration is the process of aligning mentor coaches so they read the same coaching recording the same way against ICF’s standard for the credential level. Two calibrated mentor coaches can cite different evidence on individual markers, but they reach the same answer for each competency: did the coach demonstrate it or not?

In a company, calibration usually means managers lining up their employee ratings before performance reviews. In mentor coaching it means something narrower. A mentor coach reviews recordings of a coach’s real sessions and gives feedback against the International Coaching Federation (ICF) standard for the credential the coach is working toward: the ACC Behaviorally Anchored Rating Scales (BARS) for the Associate Certified Coach (ACC) credential, the PCC Markers for the Professional Certified Coach (PCC) credential, and the MCC BARS for the Master Certified Coach (MCC) credential. Mentor coach calibration is the work of getting two mentor coaches to hear the same session and land in the same place.

I run that work in our Mentor Coach Specialization (MCS) training, where credentialed coaches learn to do this kind of review. When participants review the same recording, their forms don’t always match mine. Some of those differences are fine. Some of them change the answer, and calibration is how we sort out which is which.

It matters to coaches as well as mentors. The ICF requirements for mentor coaching put that review at the center: a mentor coach observes recorded or live sessions and gives the coach feedback on strengths and development areas. If you’re working toward an ICF credential and two mentor coaches would hear your session differently, the feedback you get depends on which one you have.

Key Takeaways

  • Calibration aims at one shared answer for each competency: did the coach demonstrate it or not? Two forms can cite different evidence on the bars and still be calibrated.
  • When forms differ, the cause is missed evidence, evidence filed under the wrong statement, or a statement read differently. In my training, it’s all three.
  • The test of a reading is the behavior: explain what the coach did and how it meets the words of the marker.
  • In a calibration discussion, a piece of evidence moves or stays where it is. Either way, everyone learns why. The alignment comes from hearing each other’s reasoning.
  • A right conclusion without the behavior behind it is probably preferential feedback, and it doesn’t belong on the form.

What Mentor Coach Calibration Aims At

Mentor coach calibration aims at one shared answer for each competency: did the coach demonstrate it or not? Two forms can differ line by line and still be calibrated. What we’re doing is calibrating and aligning, so that overall we’re seeing things the same way and understanding things the same way.

The competency is the right place to aim because that’s where ICF’s counting lands. A skill counts as demonstrated when it is rated at a competent level in at least one of the observed sessions. A competency is demonstrated when at least two-thirds (67%) of its skills are, and each coaching competency is counted on its own. The three credentials describe different levels of coaching competency, so the counts differ by level, and one level’s threshold never carries over to another.

The Competency Review Form at the end of a mentor coaching engagement records exactly that answer: for each competency, whether the coach demonstrated enough of its statements. A minimum of three Session Observation Forms, from three different sessions, inform it. In the ICF credentialing process for a portfolio application, ICF has said the coach submits only the Competency Review Form, and the Session Observation Forms are uploaded if the application is selected for audit.

Calibration also sits inside the mentor coach’s own standards. ICF describes six Mentor Coaching Competencies, a separate framework from the eight ICF Core Competencies a coach demonstrates, and one of the six is Conducts Formative Appraisals: evaluating the degree to which the mentor coaching client’s coaching aligns with the ICF Core Competencies. Two mentor coaches can only do that consistently if they read the same way.

Two columns labeled Mentor coach A and Mentor coach B highlight evidence on different rows, and lines from both lead to one banner: Same answer: was the competency demonstrated?
Calibrating at the competency. The evidence each mentor coach highlights on the bars can differ; the answer for the competency has to match.

Why Two Mentor Coaches Read One Session Differently

When participants in my training review the same recording, their forms differ from mine in three ways: evidence they missed, evidence filed under the wrong statement, and a statement read differently from how I read it. Asked which one it usually is, I’d say it’s all three. Some of those differences matter more than others.

How far apart can coaches land on one recording? Tandem’s Mentor Coaching Foundations course gives a sense of it. Every student analyzes the same recording of a 25-minute coaching session, which the course presents as a PCC-level demonstration. Of the 120 first attempts that gave an overall level, before any feedback, 37 (31%) placed it below PCC. These are students in our course (English course, May to October 2026), not participants in my training, and the full data with its caveats is in our article on how 132 first attempts placed one recording.

Markers where many pieces of evidence will do

Some markers, by their nature, could hold any number of pieces of evidence, and you don’t have to put all of them in. On both ACC and PCC there’s a bar or marker about whether the coach is asking about the client and the client’s situation: the who or the what. Almost every question is going to be about either the who or the what, so a mentor coach doesn’t need to put everything in there. It’s really just selecting which thing was the who and which was the what.

There are several markers like that. You could put a lot of things in, so just pick a few. Two mentor coaches will pick a different few, and their forms will look different on those lines without either of them being wrong.

Reading a statement differently

The second kind of difference is interpretation. On ACC, for example, there’s allowing the client to lead, and a mentor in training may have a different interpretation of what leading is. Picture a session where the client says something, and the coach pulls from what the client said and asks the next question. Some mentors in training credit that as letting the client lead. No, that’s being responsive to the client. The coach is working within the client’s topic. That is different from asking “Where would you like to go from here?” and giving the client choice.

When the difference is interpretation, we talk about the interpretation. Every word in a statement matters here. On the ACC BARS, ICF has said a statement with “and” in it needs both parts present to meet the standard. Two readers who weigh the words differently will land in different places.

Where ICF leaves blanks to fill

In my experience, ICF leaves a lot of things vague, especially on ACC. That makes it a lot harder, because you have to fill in the blanks. When a coach is working toward the ICF ACC credential, two mentor coaches can fill the same blank in two ways, and their forms will differ. Calibration is where we talk the blank through until we fill it the same way.

Two more sources

Two more sources of difference get their own articles in this series. One is squeezing evidence into a marker it doesn’t fit, because a marker with nothing under it feels like a gap to fill. The other appears when a PCC coach reviews an ACC session and cites missed opportunities that belong to PCC-level coaching and PCC-level expectations, which an ACC review doesn’t ask for. Experienced coaches bring their own coaching experience to a review, and calibration brings the expectation back to the level being reviewed.

Calibrate at the Competency, Not Every Line

Calibrated mentor coaches reach the same answer for each competency, even when their forms look different line by line. That’s the standard I hold before I trust someone in my training to offer mentor coaching. Two forms can list different statements, and slightly different ways of seeing which marker goes with what, and still be calibrated.

Say I’ve got a competency with four bars underneath it. The forms have to match on the question that sits above all four: did they actually display this competency, or did they not?

We might cite some different evidence on the bars, but we need to agree at the competency level.

There are some markers I don’t worry as much about, the ones where you could really put anything in. I’m not going to stress over whether a mentor in training picked the same short question I picked for that piece of evidence.

A difference in evidence starts to matter when it changes whether a skill counts, because enough of a competency’s skills have to count for the competency to be demonstrated. That standard is mine, and it follows the way the ICF competencies are counted.

Show Me How That’s What They’re Doing

When a mentor in training says a piece of evidence meets a marker and I’m not seeing it, I ask them to explain the specific behavior they’re seeing and how it meets this competency or this marker. If they can explain it, and it makes sense, it meets the marker.

If it’s a stretch, we go back to the marker itself. Whether it’s the ACC BARS or the PCC Markers, the wording is the standard, and the behavior has to match it. If they can’t connect what the coach did to those words, it doesn’t meet the marker. That’s how we handle that piece of the training.

Let’s read the words of that marker. This is what it says. Show me how that’s what they’re doing.

The question moves the conversation off the conclusion and onto the behavior, where both of us can check it against the same words.

What a Calibration Discussion Sounds Like

A calibration discussion starts with a question about one piece of evidence. Usually a mentor in training brings it: “Does that fit there?” Or, “On my review, this is what I put, but I’m not sure it was there.” Other times we’re reviewing somebody’s form together and I start it myself.

I’ll say, “Okay, let’s take a look at these. Read these ones for 3.4. Do you feel like these fit there, or do they fit somewhere else?” (3.4 is a marker number in Competency 3, Establishes and Maintains Agreements.) Then we have the conversation about it. Sometimes things move, sometimes they stay where they are, and sometimes the other people learn something about why it is that or why it isn’t.

I choose my words for this on purpose: we have a discussion. It’s a learning process. It’s about figuring out how to align, and the alignment comes from hearing each other’s reasoning as much as from where the evidence ends up.

I learned how much this matters early. In my first cohort, there was an extreme amount of calibration needed, and I redesigned the course around it. I’ve written about why I rebuilt the course around calibration, and why releasing mentor coaches who couldn’t yet do the evaluation was a personal ethics question for me.

When the Conclusion Comes Without the Behavior

A mentor coach can reach the right conclusion and still not be able to explain how they got there. When that happens, they’re using their own bias: what they like and what they don’t like, and what they do compared with what the mentee did. When they see what they do, they think, “Yes, that’s good.”

If they can’t tell me what behavior it is and why that behavior meets that marker, it’s probably not valid feedback. It’s probably preferential feedback, and it doesn’t belong there. Or maybe it would be a “consider.” The easiest yardstick to reach for is your own coaching style, which is exactly what doesn’t belong on the form.

They’re not trying to make the mentee coach like them. They’re trying to make sure the mentee is meeting the bar.

ICF’s guidance on written feedback points the same way. It asks mentor coaches to keep personal preference, bias and personality judgments out of their written feedback, and ICF’s bias framework asks for “disciplined evidence gathering and disciplined self-observation.” Checking your own preferences before and after a review is its own practice, and I cover it in a separate article. In a calibration discussion, the test is simpler: a conclusion that can’t be traced to a behavior isn’t ready to give a coach.

Calibrating Your Own Reading

If you mentor other coaches, you can start with your own last form. Read it again, and for each piece of evidence ask two questions: could I defend this by reading the words of the marker, and would it change whether the competency is demonstrated? The pieces you can’t defend are where a calibration discussion with another mentor coach would start.

Calibrating alone only goes so far. Whether you’re one mentor coach or a program director calibrating a coach training faculty, it takes other readers on the same recording and an experienced mentor coach to run the discussion. That’s why, if you’re choosing where to train, calibration is the first thing I’d look for in a program.

Calibration is built into how we teach mentor coaching skills in Tandem’s Mentor Coach Specialization training program, accredited under the ICF Advanced Accreditation in Mentor Coaching. Alex Kudinov and I hold the MCS at all three levels, and every mentor coach on our team holds it at the level they mentor. That matters for the profession now: from January 1, 2027, ICF has said all new mentor coaching has to come from someone who holds the MCS at that level or above. If mentor coaching is part of your coaching practice, our guide to the ICF Mentor Coach Specialization sets out what it requires, and the program is where you can develop your mentor coaching skills.

Questions About Mentor Coach Calibration

Do two calibrated mentor coaches have to cite the same evidence?

Two calibrated mentor coaches can cite different evidence on the bars. What has to match is the answer for each competency: did the coach demonstrate it or not? On markers where many pieces of evidence would do, I don’t stress over whether someone picked the same question I did.

Can evidence from two recordings count toward one marker?

ICF has said that evidence for a marker can’t be accumulated across sessions. Whatever a marker needs has to be there within one session, so two mentor coaches calibrating on a marker are comparing what happened in the same recording.

Why is ACC harder to calibrate?

In my experience, ICF leaves a lot of things vague on ACC, so mentor coaches have to fill in the blanks, and two of them can fill a blank differently. Every word of an ACC BARS statement counts: when a statement includes “and,” both parts must be present to meet the standard.

Is feedback valid if the mentor coach can’t name the behavior?

Probably not. If a mentor coach can’t say what behavior it is and why it meets the marker, it’s probably preferential feedback. At most it would be a “consider.” The aim is to make sure the mentee is meeting the bar.

What is good mentor coaching feedback?

Good mentor coaching feedback describes what the coach did: you asked an open question, you summarized what the client said. It leaves the coach’s style alone. It suggests a type of question to consider and leaves the words to the coach. It is written so the mentee can use it when the mentor coach is not in the room.

There are two ways to tell a coach about a question that didn’t land. One sounds like this: “You said it like this, you should say it like this.” The other sounds like this: “Consider asking the client what they’re believing in this moment.” Both are about the same moment in a recording. One gives the coach my words. The other gives them something to try.

I mean feedback in the International Coaching Federation (ICF) sense. A coach working toward an ICF credential at the Associate Certified Coach (ACC), Professional Certified Coach (PCC) or Master Certified Coach (MCC) level submits a recording of a coaching session, and a mentor coach listens to it, reads the transcript and gives feedback against ICF’s standard for that level. That feedback is a large part of how a coach gets ready to earn their ICF certification, and it’s what I teach mentor coaches to write in Tandem’s Mentor Coach Specialization (MCS) training.

I write the behavior beside every piece of evidence. That’s my interpretation of what ICF asks for, and it’s how I mentor now. Here is what that feedback says.

Key Takeaways

  • Good feedback describes behavior the coach can find in the recording: you asked an open question, you summarized what the client said, you acknowledged the client.
  • Style, whether encouraging, friendly, challenging or all business, stays out of the feedback. There’s no right way to show up as a coach.
  • A “consider” points the coach toward a type of question and leaves the words to them. A script hands over the words.
  • Check your bias before you review a recording and again after. Liking a coach’s style doesn’t mean they meet the competencies.
  • ICF asks written feedback to name at least two competencies as strengths and two as development opportunities, each tied to behavioral statements or markers.

What Good Mentor Coaching Feedback Names

Good mentor coaching feedback names what the coach did, in words the coach can recognize and repeat. It describes behavior: a specific thing that happened in the coaching session, at a point you can find in the recording. Then it connects that behavior to the competency it shows, or to the place where the coach still has room to grow.

Feedback on behavior is: this is what you did. You asked a question about this. You summarized what the client said. You asked an open question. You acknowledged the client. I can actually describe the behavior you did.

Each of those sentences names a specific skill the coach can find in their own recording and use with the next client, whatever that client’s goal. Summarizing what the client said is active listening the coach can see on the page. None of it asks the coach to guess what I meant.

What ICF asks written feedback to contain

ICF gives written feedback a structure. Its guidance on evaluation feedback asks the mentor coach to identify at least two competencies from the ICF Core Competencies as strengths and at least two as development opportunities, and to tie each Core Competency it names, such as Establishes and Maintains Agreements, to the behavioral statements or markers behind it. The development areas should match the weaker demonstrated areas. The same statement or marker shouldn’t appear as both a strength and a development area, because that creates mixed messaging. And the language stays free of personal preference, bias, personality judgments and verdicts.

Feedback is verbal and written, every session. The Session Observation Form carries the written feedback for each session, and the Competency Review Form gathers it across the mentoring. The coach also reflects on their own strengths and areas of growth, a required part of each session. That is what ICF requires of mentor coaching feedback, and Tandem’s free forms for each level are built for writing it.

Writing the behavior beside each piece of evidence goes past that structure. That part is mine, because the behavior is what the coach can take to another client.

Feedback on Behavior Versus Style

Behavior is what the coach did. Style is maybe the way you asked the question, and it’s so hard to describe. Somebody’s style might be encouraging, so they give a lot of encouragement throughout the process. Maybe they’re friendly, and maybe they’re challenging. Maybe they create a space that feels like friends in a relationship, or one that feels like all business. Those are style things.

There’s no right way to show up as a coach. There are behaviors you exhibit as a coach, and those behaviors are what say you’re competent or not competent. So my feedback stays on the behaviors. An encouraging coach and an all-business coach can both ask an open question, summarize what the client said and acknowledge the client. Their styles differ. The behaviors are the same, and they show the same competence.

Behavior or style: name the behavior, such as asking an open question, summarizing what the client said, acknowledging the client or asking one direct question; leave the style alone, whether encouraging, friendly, challenging or all business
Behavior or style? The feedback names what the coach did, and the style stays with the coach.

ICF’s own language points the same way. Its Mentor Coaching Competency 5, Facilitates Client’s Skill Development, “supports the mentor coaching client’s development of coaching skills, and unique coaching style.” Its guidance for written feedback rules out personal preference and personality judgments. The style belongs to the coach. The feedback belongs with the behavioral statements of the ACC and MCC Behaviorally Anchored Rating Scales (BARS) and with the PCC Markers.

I’ve written before about feedback that names the behavior under the words, and about keeping style for the mentoring conversation and out of the rating. Here the point is narrower. Whatever you write on the form, the coach should be able to read it and see an action, never a personality.

Try it on the last feedback you wrote. Which sentences describe something the coach did, and which describe how the coach came across?

How to Give Feedback Without Handing Over a Script

You give feedback without handing over a script by offering the coach a kind of move to try and leaving the words to them. A script tells the coach what to say next time. An example invites them to consider a type of question or a possibility, and the coach finds their own words for it with the next client.

Handing them a script is, “You said it like this, you should say it like this,” or, “What you should have asked here is this,” or, “What I would have asked here is this.” Offering an example, I think, is more like: consider asking this type of question next time. Consider what would happen if you did this. Consider asking the client what they’re believing in this moment. It’s not, “Here are the words you need to use.”

A consider points the coach’s next steps in a direction and stops there. The coach who knows the behavior can find new words with every client. The coach who was handed my question has one question, and it fits one client on one day.

The instinct to hand over the better question is strong, and it shows up in our own data. In Tandem’s Mentor Coaching Foundations course (161 students in the English course, May to October 2026), students write a developmental feedback document to the coach in a recorded session. In the feedback on those submissions, reviewers flagged scripting in 33 comments. On feedback work that was accepted, the most common growth note, in 28 comments, was the same thing: a word-for-word question for the coach to use next time, even when the student framed it as an invitation.

The full numbers, including how many first drafts offered the coach example questions at all, are in our piece on the habit of directing instead of developing.

Ask Why Before You Name the Behavior

When a coach’s wording gets in the way, I ask why before I offer anything. The coach’s answer points to the behavior, and the behavior is what the feedback needs to name. A better question would fix one moment in one session. The behavior behind the extra words can show up again with any client until the coach sees it.

There are times when the coach is adding extra words, and those extra words aren’t helping. Or they ask a second question, or they clarify the question, and you would have done better to just stick with the first question. It was a good question.

So we have a discussion about why. Why did you clarify this question? Why did you add another question? What made you ask a question, then explain the question, and then ask a different question? Were you thinking and talking at the same time? Did you not trust that the client could understand the question? What was happening?

I can hear a stacked question when I listen to the recording. What I can’t hear is what the coach was trying to achieve with the second one, and their answer gives us both that insight. The why is what lets us define the behavior. From there we partner on the change, and the better question is theirs to find.

That way we can identify the behavior you need to change, not the question you need to ask.

Check Your Bias Before and After

Before I give feedback on a recording, I check my own bias, and I check it again after. The phrase I use is “check your bias at the door.” If this is somebody I really like, and I like their style, am I going to automatically say they meet the competencies? No. I need to actually state facts.

Just because I like the way they coach doesn’t mean they meet the competencies.

So check your bias before you do anything, and then check it again after you’ve done it, to make sure you haven’t looked at it through biased eyes. Make sure there’s no conflict of interest.

Which of my own preferences shows up most? I don’t know. Actually, I guess I do know. I like to balance challenge and support, and when I hear coaches challenging their clients, not confrontational, but direct, that makes my heart sing. But if they aren’t challenging, that’s a style thing. Asking a direct question, instead of asking three questions or softening all the questions so you don’t hurt anybody’s feelings, is a behavior. Being a challenging coach is a style.

When you notice a pull toward a coach, ask whether it comes from the behavior or the style. A direct question belongs in the feedback. Noticing your own pull is reflective practice, and a recording asks for it as much as a client does.

ICF’s guidance on bias gives the check two sides: “doing,” which is disciplined evidence gathering, and “being,” which is disciplined self-observation. It names 12 bias types, among them similarity, cultural style, and energy or expressiveness. Several of them are ways a coach’s style can color what you observe and how you evaluate it.

The same gap shows up in the feedback on submissions to our Mentor Coaching Foundations course. Among the developmental feedback documents sent back on a first attempt, 45% had no bias self-check, and 25% had a missing or thin acknowledgment of the coach’s style. Those are shares of the work sent back, not of every student. The strongest work did the check properly: it named a specific preference, showed how it colored the first read, and went back to the evidence.

Judgment Words Are Emotion

Judgment words report how the mentor coach felt about the coaching, and they leave the coach nothing to work with. That was good. That was great. That felt icky. Those aren’t behaviors; that’s emotion. A coach can repeat a behavior with the next client. Nobody can repeat “great.”

Praise slips into feedback as easily as distaste does. Calling a question great feels kind, and it still leaves the coach guessing which part worked. A mentor coach brings their knowledge of the competencies to the feedback, and a judgment word uses none of it. Competency-based feedback replaces the adjective with the behavior: you asked one open question, then let the client think.

ICF’s guidance asks the same of written feedback: no personal preference, no personality judgments. “That felt icky” is both. There’s a second trap close to this one, going through the form line by line from a place of assessment, and it deserves its own article.

Write It for When Your Mentee Is Not in the Room

Write your feedback for the week after the session, when your mentee is on their own with it. That’s why having the behaviors on there is important. We don’t want them to just go practice the same questions. We want them to look at the behaviors and see how they need to interact with their client.

So really consider how you write up that feedback. How are they going to be able to use this when they’re not in the room with you, when they’re trying to implement this feedback in their coaching? It’s worth spending the extra time and giving them all the information. It’s also feedback written for the mentee to keep: ICF has said the mentoring client is the one who holds the forms.

Picture a coach new to the profession, alone with the form a week later, before their next coaching session. A line that says a marker was met tells them where they stood. A line that names the behavior under each coaching competency tells them what to do again, and that is the valuable part of the record. So here’s the practical test for every sentence you write: could the coach act on it with nobody to ask?

I’ve had people say, “Well, can’t I just put three things, like, ‘Yep, they met each one of those markers’?” Well, technically you could. But is that going to be the best thing for your mentee?

Don’t do the minimum you can do and get away with. Do what’s right by your mentee.

This is the feedback I teach mentor coaches to write. Alex Kudinov and I hold the MCS at all three levels, and every mentor coach on our team holds it at the level they mentor. Our overview of the Mentor Coach Specialization sets out what ICF requires at each level, and Tandem’s mentor coach training cohort is where we teach this work.

On the next recording you review, check your bias before you start and again when you finish. Then read your feedback once the way your mentee will, alone.

Questions About Mentor Coaching Feedback

How many strengths and development areas does ICF ask for in written feedback?

At least two Core Competencies as strengths and at least two as development opportunities, each tied to the behavioral statements or markers behind it. The development areas should match the weaker demonstrated areas, and the same statement or marker shouldn’t appear as both.

What’s the difference between feedback on behavior and feedback on style?

Behavior is what the coach did: asked an open question, summarized what the client said, acknowledged the client. Style is how the coach shows up: encouraging, friendly, challenging or all business. There’s no right way to show up as a coach, so the feedback names the behavior.

Is suggesting a question the same as handing over a script?

A script gives the coach the exact words, such as “What I would have asked here is this.” An example invites the coach to consider a type of question or a possibility and leaves the wording to them.

Does mentor coaching feedback have to be written?

ICF’s handbook calls for verbal and written feedback from the mentor coach every session: written feedback on each Session Observation Form and cumulative written feedback on the Competency Review Form. ICF staff have described an accommodation for feedback delivered only verbally; confirm it with ICF in writing before you rely on it.

How do you review a coaching recording?

Listen to the whole session first for tone of voice, pace and silence. Then go line by line through the transcript and mark every line against the standard for the credential level, noting the timestamp, the words and the behavior. Go back for what has no timestamp, such as silence. Then write it up for the next conversation.

Before I read a single line of a transcript, I listen. The audio tells me things the page can’t: the coach’s tone of voice, the speed they’re talking at, whether there’s any silence. That first listen is one level of understanding, and it’s where my review of every coaching recording begins.

Mentor coaching is a specific kind of mentorship. A coach working toward an International Coaching Federation (ICF) credential at the Associate Certified Coach (ACC), Professional Certified Coach (PCC) or Master Certified Coach (MCC) level sends a recording of a real coaching session. A mentor coach reviews it against ICF’s standard for that level: the ACC Behaviorally Anchored Rating Scales (BARS), the PCC Markers or the MCC BARS. If you’re a mentor coach, or a mentor in training, reviewing another coach’s recording, this is the order of work I follow. If you’re the coach who sent the recording, this is what happens to it.

What follows is a high-level overview, because the whole process would take me forever to describe. It covers the three times I go through a recording, the test I use to tell evidence from impression, how I read a competency in context, and how I write it up.

Key Takeaways

  • Listen to the whole recording before you read the transcript closely. The audio carries tone of voice, pace and silence. The transcript loses them.
  • Go line by line and give every line a mark: it meets the bar, it’s below the bar, the coach didn’t do it, or it wasn’t applicable. Note the timestamp, the words and the behavior.
  • Evidence is something the coach did that you can point to and explain against all the words of the marker. What new mentor coaches usually miss: they squeeze evidence into a marker so it looks met.
  • Read each competency in the context of the whole session. A few stacked questions pasted into the form don’t mean the competency wasn’t demonstrated.
  • A careful review takes time. A 30-minute recording takes me about an hour and a half to write up, and a 60-minute recording two to two and a half hours.

What a Review Is For, and What ICF Counts

A review gives the coach something to learn from before their next recording, whatever certification level they’re working toward. That makes it a different job from assessment, where the point is a verdict on the recording. ICF’s unit of judgment is the session: a skill counts when the coach demonstrates it at a competent level in at least one observed session.

The standard comes from the ICF Core Competencies, read through the statements for the level: the ACC BARS, the PCC Markers or the MCC BARS. A competency is demonstrated when at least two-thirds (67%) of its skills are. The number of skills differs by competency and by level, so one level’s threshold table never carries over to another. That is what ICF requires of mentor coaching, and it shapes every coaching session I review.

Two competencies work differently. Competency 1, ethical practice, is a yes or no check. Competency 2, the coaching mindset, isn’t rated from the session at the ACC or MCC level, and ICF has said it carries no score at PCC either. So I don’t go hunting for mindset evidence to rate.

Writing down the behavior behind every piece of evidence is my method, and it’s how we mentor at Tandem. ICF’s own requirements for written feedback come later in this article. The method exists so the coach can see their coaching skills clearly enough to grow them.

Listen to the Whole Session First

I start by making sure we have an accurate transcript, and then I listen to the whole recording before I read anything closely. I’m hearing the big picture: the coach’s tone of voice, what speed they’re talking at, whether there’s silence. Getting the audio version is one level of understanding, and the transcript alone can’t give it.

The transcript loses things. Sometimes I read what the coach said and think, “I’m so confused, I don’t know what they’re saying here.” When I listened to it, I understood. Reading it, I have no clue. That tells me the coach’s questions aren’t clear. A question could be long, but sometimes I just can’t read the language they’re using and understand it. I would have to be listening to it.

I hold what I notice on that first listen as context. An unclear question I could only follow by ear is more of an impression than evidence, and the difference between the two comes back later in this article. The first listen gives me the overall picture of the recorded session, and everything after it is closer reading.

How a mentor coach reviews a coaching recording: listen to the whole session for tone, pace and silence, go line by line through the transcript for timestamp, words and behavior, go back for what has no timestamp, then write it up for the next conversation
Three trips through a recording. The audio gives the context, the transcript gives the evidence, and the overview catches what has no single timestamp.

Go Line by Line Through the Transcript

Next I go line by line through the transcript and decide, for each thing the coach said or did, where it sits against the standard. Either it meets the bar, it’s below the bar, they didn’t do it at all, or it wasn’t applicable. I go through the entire transcript, all of it, and every line gets a mark.

For a coach preparing for the ICF ACC credential, that standard is the ACC BARS. For PCC, it’s the ICF PCC Markers. I’m also checking the other direction: whether a moment sits above the bar, really a PCC marker rather than an ACC bar. How listening differs between the levels is a subject of its own, so I’ll leave it there.

Then I write it on the form, in the same order every time. “Here’s the timestamp. Here are the words you used.” And then: “And here’s the behavior I’m seeing or hearing happen.” Sometimes that behavior is exactly what the competency says, and sometimes it’s different. Some competencies can be shown by doing this, this or this, so I’m identifying which one the coach is doing.

If there’s something the coach says that I don’t mark, that was intentional, because it didn’t meet a bar or a marker. An unmarked line is a decision I can explain, the same as a marked one.

All the words of the bar or the marker are important. ICF’s guide to the ACC BARS makes one version of this explicit: when a statement includes “and,” both parts must be present to meet the standard. Reading every word is what keeps the documentation on the form honest, and it gives the coach specific evidence they can find again in their own recording.

Go Back for What Has No Timestamp

After the first listen and the line-by-line work, I go over what I’ve written and look for areas I haven’t covered. Some things don’t sit on any single line of the transcript. Silence is the clearest example, so I think about how silence showed up and how the coach used it, and I might go back and listen to part of the recording.

I’m not necessarily going to find a timestamp for silence.

This is my third time through the recording, and I treat it as an overview. What did I miss that will round it out? That way I can tell whether a marker really didn’t show up, or whether I just didn’t catch it going line by line because it was a bigger-picture thing, not a single timestamp.

ICF’s PCC Markers guide treats one marker this way too. Marker 7.8 is judged on the coaching session in its entirety, and it also needs more than one clear piece of evidence. What ICF doesn’t allow is borrowing across sessions. Evidence for one marker can’t be added up from two recordings, so the marker is demonstrated inside one session or not at all.

Listening again for silence gives me an insight the line-by-line work can’t. It’s also where I notice the bigger-picture things that run through the whole session.

Evidence Versus Impression

Evidence is something the coach actually did or didn’t do. I can point to it in the transcript, and I can explain the behavior and why that behavior met the competency, the marker or the bar. An impression is something I sensed but can’t point to that way, and it doesn’t go on the form as evidence.

An impression can still tell me something. The question I couldn’t read on paper tells me the coach’s questions aren’t clear, but that’s more of an impression. The speed of talking is another. I can’t look at a timestamp and say, “You were talking faster than the client,” but I can hear it. ICF’s bias awareness guidance names twelve types of bias a reviewer has to watch for in themselves, and pacing or rhythm is one of them.

Then there’s style. If a coach is using a different style than I would use, I can’t judge the style. I have to mark the competency. For other reviewers, I would say that’s bias: they don’t like the style. Giving feedback on behavior rather than style is a skill of its own.

We see the same pull toward impression in Tandem’s Mentor Coaching Foundations course. In feedback on submissions from 161 students in the English course between May and October 2026, many stated a level from their overall impression of the session. Of the first-attempt session analyses we asked students to redo, 25% reached no overall level conclusion at all, and 20% made observations without tying them to a credential level. Among our notes on analyses we accepted, 15 pointed to evidence written down without a timestamp.

Read Each Competency in Context

I read a competency across the whole session. If the coach did something consistently throughout and there were two times they did the opposite, they did it right most of the time, so that meets. My feedback says both: overall you did this, this marker is met, and here are two instances where it was below, so let’s look at why.

Then they learn from that.

They don’t have to get everything right.

Stacked questions are a good example. There are times when I’m reviewing a recording and what I paste into the form is, “Look, they asked a stacked question here,” and I might paste three different stacked questions. That doesn’t mean the competency wasn’t demonstrated, because what I didn’t paste in there was the 36 questions they asked that weren’t stacked. I have to take things in context.

So I do one of two things. I go and grab ten questions that do meet, ones that aren’t stacked, or I write a summary note citing the evidence: throughout the session, asked short open-ended questions one at a time. There were a few instances of stacked questions, and we’ll discuss those in the session. But it still meets.

ICF’s PCC Markers guide describes reviewers gathering and weighing evidence and contra-evidence before deciding whether a marker is marked. In our Mentor Coaching Foundations course, we saw students name the same competency as both a strength and a gap in one session, and there’s more on what those session analyses showed in a separate piece.

What New Mentor Coaches Miss: Squeezing Evidence Into a Marker

In my experience training mentor coaches, what they usually miss is this: they don’t read all the words of a marker. They feel like their job is to find evidence that every marker was met. So they squeeze things in where they don’t fit, because they’re thinking, “Oh, I don’t have anything for that marker.”

Just because you have a marker that’s not met doesn’t mean you get to shove anything in there just to say it was met.

Reading the markers as a checklist to complete pushes a reviewer this way. Something may fit a marker, but that doesn’t make it evidence for the one that’s empty. My test is simple. If I can’t describe why it met the bar, this is the behavior you did and this is why it met the bar, then it doesn’t meet. Anything else would be me trying to make something meet that doesn’t really meet.

When a reviewer reaches a conclusion they can’t explain behavior by behavior, it’s usually their preference talking, and that’s where calibration between mentor coaches comes in. It’s the same reason the question at the center of what makes a good mentor coach is whether they did what the marker says.

Writing the Feedback for the Next Conversation

Once the form is filled in, I go through each competency and give the coach an overview: how this competency showed up, what was strong, and where any challenges in it are showing up. Then I write their main strengths, usually three or so, and the development areas, always with the next recording in mind.

ICF’s guidance sets a floor for written feedback. It asks for at least two competencies as strengths and at least two as development opportunities, each tied to a specific behavioral statement or marker and anchored in observable evidence. It also rules out language that reflects personal preference, bias or personality judgments, or that reads as a verdict. ICF’s handbook describes verbal and written feedback from the mentor coach on the coach’s strengths and development areas.

In the conversation, I focus the coach on the most important thing. If you’re going to focus on one thing between now and the next time we meet, this is what you should focus on. Sometimes that’s “You really need to focus on your coaching agreement.” If it’s a big thing like that, it’s the only thing I give them, and in that next recording we want to see the coaching agreement. I’m not going to drown them with every nitpicky thing.

That focus becomes the coach’s next steps, and it’s what I look for in the next recording. Everything in the write-up serves the mentor coaching relationship and the next conversation. The goal is a better coach on the next recording.

ICF expects at least three Session Observation Forms, from three different live or recorded sessions, and one Competency Review Form across them. We built free forms for each level. From January 1, 2027, ICF has said new mentor coaching has to come from someone holding the Mentor Coach Specialization (MCS) at that level or above.

How Long a Careful Review Takes

In my practice, recordings run 20 minutes to an hour. One that’s 30 minutes long takes me about an hour and a half to write up. A 60-minute recording takes two to two and a half hours, and anything else falls somewhere in between. That time is the real cost of mentoring this way.

Those lengths are my agreement terms. ICF has said mentor coaching has no minimum or maximum length, only that it is a full, complete coaching session. The familiar window of 20-60 minutes is an ICF performance evaluation rule. A performance evaluation recording is part of some ICF credential applications, and ICF has said it will take no new ACC or PCC portfolio applications with a performance evaluation from April 1, 2027, so it’s worth knowing what replaces the performance evaluation.

If you’d rather skip the review and just have the conversation, you probably need to be an instructor, not a mentor. I’ve written more about how much work mentor coaching is.

Pick one recording, your own or one you’re reviewing, and make one of these trips through it on purpose. Which line did you leave unmarked, and was that a decision? If you want to build this skill with practice reviewing a peer’s recordings and debriefing them live in class, that’s how we train mentor coaches to review recordings. Our overview of the Mentor Coach Specialization covers what each level requires and what changes on January 1, 2027.

Frequently Asked Questions About Reviewing a Coaching Recording

Do I need the audio if I have a transcript?

Yes. The audio carries the coach’s tone of voice, the speed they talk at and any silence, and silence has no timestamp. Some questions only make sense when you hear them. If you can’t follow a question on paper, listen to that part of the recording before you decide what it shows.

Can evidence from two recordings be combined for one marker?

No. ICF has confirmed that evidence for a marker can’t be accumulated across sessions. Where a PCC Marker needs more than one clear piece of evidence, every piece has to come from the same session. A skill counts as demonstrated when the coach shows it at a competent level in at least one observed session.

What if the coach’s style is different from mine?

Mark the competency. If a coach uses a different style than you would, you can’t judge the style. Ask whether the behavior meets the bar or the marker, and keep your own preference off the form. A judgment you can’t explain behavior by behavior is usually preference.

How many strengths and development areas should written feedback name?

ICF’s guidance asks for at least two competencies as strengths and at least two as development opportunities, each tied to a behavioral statement or marker with observable evidence. I usually name three or so strengths. In the conversation, I focus the coach on the development area that matters most before their next recording.